Indictment dismissed against MN state trooper accused of manslaughter in crash that killed 2


A judge dismissed an indictment against a Minnesota state trooper charged with manslaughter in a 2014 crash that killed two people.

Scott Reps was responding to a collision between a motorcycle and a deer when he broadsided a vehicle that pulled out in front of his squad car as he drove through Cannon Falls on July 4, 2014.

The passengers in the car, Norman Scott, 78, and his wife, Geneva Scott, 79, from Cannon Falls, both died at the scene. Reps was seriously injured.


Reps, 49, who had his squad lights flashing and siren going at the time of the crash, was accused of speeding, going 80 mph at the time of the crash, the Republican Eagle reports.

He was indicted last December by a grand jury in Goodhue County on two counts of second-degree manslaughter and driving without due care. This indictment was rare, the Star Tribune says police and law enforcement officers are usually not charged when they are involved in a fatal accident.

And last week, Goodhue County Judge David Knutson filed paperwork dismissing the indictment, reports note.

This came after Reps' defense attorney filed a motion over the summer claiming "prosecutorial misconduct", KARE 11 reports.

Knutson said Reps' rights were violated when he was coerced into giving a statement on threat of termination, which was later used against him, WCCO notes.

The judge also said prosecutors should have told the grand jury Norman Scott failed to yield before the crash, the Republican Eagle says.

Prosecutors can now request another grand jury and include the information that was left out, the paper notes.

Next Up

Kirk Cousins

Buy or sell the Minnesota Vikings as a true contender?

The schedule is daunting, but the Vikings have a chance to show the world that they're the real deal.

Pixabay - footballs stock

School board won't comment on 'police investigation' involving football team

The Proctor School Board chair stated their policy during Monday's board meeting.


Motorcyclist killed on I-94 may have been braking for animal

The crash closed I-94 in Wisconsin for three hours.

curl mesabi curling club

Curling Olympic trials will be held on the Iron Range instead of California

Mixed doubles curling has been moved to Minnesota over COVID-19 concerns.

sun country landline

Sun Country to offer luxury car service to MSP Airport

It's Sun Country's new Door-to-Door service, in partnership with Landline.

st. paul homicide - 30 block of Winnipeg Avenue West

St. Paul man arrested after calling police to report he killed his wife

The man was outside the police station when he called 911.


Highly contagious rabbit disease detected for first time in MN

Two indoor rabbits "died suddenly and inexplicably" from the disease earlier this month.

Salted Nut Roll

New seasonal varieties of the Salted Nut Roll have arrived

There will never be enough pumpkin spice to satisfy the world.

covid-19, coronavirus

Minnesota's COVID-19 update for Tuesday, September 28

The newest information provided by the Minnesota Department of Health.

police lights

Minnesota man charged after 3-hour standoff with police on I-94 in Wisconsin

Law enforcement used tear gas on him in an effort to get him out of the vehicle.

Pamela Espeland (1)

Beloved MinnPost writer who amplified MN arts scene dies suddenly

The arts community is remembering her impact and mourning her death.