It's taken three decades, but police now know who killed Duluth teen in 1981


The murder of Duluth teenager Carolyn Andrew has remained unsolved for almost 34 years, but police say the case has now been cracked thanks to advances in DNA technology.

The 17-year-old was discovered in a shallow grave at Twin Ponds, near Enger Park, on May 6, 1981, having been killed by a single bullet wound to the head, according to a news release from the Minnesota Department of Public Safety.

While there is no answer to the how and the why of Andrew's murder, her friends and relatives now at least have the identity of the man thought to be responsible for the killing.

The Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension and Duluth Police Department have announced they have linked DNA found on the aspiring model's body to Cecil Wayne Oliver.

According to the Northland News Center, Oliver died from a single gunshot wound to the head in 1988, at the age of 30.

"Through excellent evidence collection and preservation along with solid investigative work done at the onset of this tragic case we were able to bring it a conclusion with the help of modern technology," Duluth Police Department Chief Gordon Ramsey said in the news release.

How the case was solved

Over the years, advances in DNA testing enabled investigators to build a full DNA profile of the suspect based on the male DNA found on Andrew's body, police say.

No matching profiles were found in state or national DNA databases during previous searches, but another search in March 2014 discovered a partial match to a known offender, meaning the suspect in the Andrew murder was likely to be a close relative of that person.

This led investigators to Oliver, who according to WJON, lived in Duluth at the time of Andrew's death, and prompted authorities to obtain permission to get a DNA sample from his remains.

This sample matched the DNA found on Andrew's body.

The Andrew murder

Andrew's body was found facedown, partially submerged in Twin Ponds, having died from a single, small-caliber bullet to her head, the DPS release notes.

She left her parents' house on Farley Lane, in the Woodland Area of Duluth, at 8 p.m. on the evening of May 5 to walk to the nearby Ridgeview Lanes bowling alley to meet friends, the release says.

But she never arrived at the bowling alley and her body was spotted the next day at around 2.15 p.m. by a passerby below Skyline Parkway.

Investigators believe that Andrew and Oliver had an encounter the night before her disappearance at the Cove Bar in Superior, the Duluth News Tribune says, with witnesses describing a man named "Cecil" repeatedly talking to Andrew and trying to get her phone number.

While there are still unanswered questions about her murder, the discovery of the DNA match to Oliver means police have officially closed the case.

Next Up

Screen Shot 2021-10-19 at 8.11.35 PM

Watch: Marcus Foligno starts fight with a superman punch

Foligno was not messing around in the first period.

Union Gospel Mission graffiti side by side - Duluth PD

Vandals target longstanding Duluth soup kitchen, transitional housing site

Union Gospel Mission has been operating in the city since 1922.

i-94 crash st. michael - 2021.10.19

At least 1 dead after 'serious crash' on I-94 in St. Michael

That side of the highway is expected to be closed for at least a few hours.

House for sale

The crazy Twin Cities housing market is showing signs of slowing down

Agents are seeing fewer multiple offers and no inspections are less prevalent.

Ben Simmons

Simmons' reunion with 76ers lasts mere days, chance for Wolves?

Woj says the Sixers remain "steadfast" in their plans for Simmons.

mitchell ottinger

Sub teacher involved in 'sextortion' of more than 10 minors pleads guilty

Some of the minors he knew from the school district where he worked.

flickr ice castles new brighton 2020 - Greg Gjerdingen

The Ice Castles, a winter favorite, are coming back to the Twin Cities

The popular attraction was canceled last winter due to COVID.

joey meatballs

4 new vendors coming to Rosedale's POTLUCK food hall

Three restaurants and a VR company are opening soon.

flickr - Lorie Shaull - Line 3 pipeline Palisade July 2021

Enbridge misses deadline to fix its groundwater blunder

The company had 30 days to stop the leak it caused by not following its submitted plans.

wikimedia commons - the beach boys 2019 - joergens.mi

Beach Boys bringing 2021 holiday tour to Minnesota

The iconic band's "Holiday Harmonies" tour stops at Treasure Island just before the new year.