Skip to main content

Judge denies release of 2 sex offenders, challenges overarching program

  • Author:
  • Updated:

Two individuals who have been cited as examples of the systemic issues plaguing the Minnesota Sex Offender Program will not be released or transferred to a new facility as requested, the Star Tribune reports.

U.S. District Judge Donovan Frank issued a 38-page ruling Monday, opting not to provide immediate relief for the individuals – 24-year-old male who never committed a crime as an adult, and a 48-year-old who is the only female at an otherwise all-male facility, MinnPost reports.

Explainer: MN Sex Offender Program

The Minnesota Sex Offender Program (MSOP) provides services to individuals who have been court-ordered to receive treatment.

Those people are not prisoners, but have completed their sentences and are civilly committed to the program by the courts for an undetermined amount of time. The department says there are currently about 697 clients in the MSOP, spread across two facilities: Moose Lake and St. Peter.

In order to be discharged from the program, a committed offender must petition for approval from the Supreme Court Appeal Panel. The panel considers a handful of factors when deciding whether to release or transfer someone, including a person's clinical treatment progress, the potential danger to public safety and "the need for continued institutionalization."

Only one person has been successfully discharged from the program since its creation in 1995.

But Frank did suggest there are serious systemic issues with the sex offender program. (The full ruling was posted online by MinnPost.)

The Minnesota Sex Offender Program (MSOP) has been the target of constant criticism in recent months, having been previously called “clearly broken” by Frank because it commits offenders indefinitely, despite their prison sentence having already been served. State lawmakers have been put under pressure to reform the program, but an effort this past legislative session stalled.

In Frank's Monday ruling, he said he will speed up a class-action lawsuit filed by 14 plaintiffs, all of whom are currently civilly committed to the MSOP. A pretrial date is set for Aug. 21, to determine the start of the trial.

'Would have likely languished for years'

Last month a group of four court-appointed experts – one each from Minnesota, Florida, New York and Wisconsin. – said the treatment of the two individuals was insufficient. They suggested the male be immediately released, because treatment for a crime committed as an adolescent is different than what's needed for an adult.

The female should be transferred from the all-male facility they said, and the state should come up with a new treatment program for her. She’s the only woman ever committed to the 19-year-old program.

In his Monday ruling, Frank acknowledged the issues facing both offenders.

The male, he said, "would likely have languished for years in the prison-like environment of MSOP-Moose Lake without any realistic hope of gaining his freedom" if the lawsuit hadn't been filed.

"And of course it is of great concern to the Court that this may not be an aberrant case of system failure but is symptomatic of a larger systemic problem of constitutional concern," he continued.

He called the treatment of the female offender "grossly inadequate – even shocking."

A state Department of Health and Human Services official told WCCO they are pleased the two individuals were not released, adding they plan to defend the constitutionality of the sex offender program.

Next Up

minneapolis police

Man fatally shot overnight in north Minneapolis

The shooting was reported around 2:20 a.m.

Screen Shot 2022-05-22 at 8.30.08 AM

Campsites closed at Voyageurs National Park due to 'historic' water levels

All backcountry trails and campsites are closed, as well as many frontcountry sites.

state capitol Minnesota

Lawmakers reach agreement on tax cuts ahead of session's end

Lawmakers announced they had reached a deal on a tax bill Saturday ahead of the looming session deadline.


Victims of daytime drive-by shooting in Robbinsdale identified

The two men died after a hail of bullets struck a vehicle.

Screen Shot 2022-05-22 at 8.14.37 AM

Source of 'loud explosion' in Brooklyn Park a mystery

The noise was investigated by police, but no source could be determined.

covid, vaccine, booster shots

COVID: All Americans over 50 advised to get a second booster

Cases, hospitalizations and deaths are on the rise again as new COVID variants emerge.

J.W. Peck (left) and Eric Galler.

2 Minnesotans inducted into White Castle's Hall of Fame

White Castle — it's what a man in Minneapolis and another in Woodbury, crave.

Screen Shot 2022-05-21 at 5.46.37 PM

Video shows officers ended pursuit before fatal crash in Anoka

The crash occurred when the driver fled police during an attempted traffic stop in Coon Rapids.

Eli Hart

6-year-old Eli Hart identified as boy found dead in car trunk

The kindergartner's father was trying to get full custody of his son.


Boy found dead in trunk of car in Mound was kindergartner

"It is horrifying and difficult to process a tragedy of this magnitude, especially in our close-knit community," the superintendent wrote.

Minneapolis police

Man found yelling for help after being shot in Minneapolis

The shooting occurred on the 800 block of Elwood Avenue North at around 9:15 p.m.

Screen Shot 2022-05-21 at 9.56.21 AM

Minneapolis North principal says she was fired, district says otherwise

“MPS requires schools to follow protocols in times like that and I did not,” Friestleben said.