Skip to main content

Judge to rule on whether to block union effort to organize home daycares

  • Author:
  • Updated:

A federal judge says he plans to rule soon on whether plans to put together a union vote among Minnesota daycare providers should proceed.

As the Associated Press reports, Judge Michael Davis heard arguments Thursday over two lawsuits challenging the new law that gives the American Federation of State County and Municipal Employees permission to try to organize certain providers.

The Legislature voted in May to allow AFSCME to try to organize providers who look after kids whose care is subsidized by the state.

The Star Tribune reports the plaintiffs urged Judge Davis to put a stop to any union vote and throw out the law. Lawyers for the state and the union, meanwhile, argued it's the lawsuits that should be thrown out and a union vote should be allowed to move ahead.

Home daycare providers opposed to the law say it intrudes on independent businesses and may lead some to drop families that get state subsidies in order to avoid having to pay union dues.

MPR reports Gov. Mark Dayton calls it a travesty that providers might be prevented from deciding whether join a union.

The bill was hotly debated at the Legislature this spring and passed the House by the slimmest of margins, with all the Republicans and a few DFLers voting against it.

A poll taken by the Star Tribune last month found more disagreed with the Legislature's move than approved of it.

The challenges to Minnesota's law have attracted the attention of national pro-union and anti-union groups, which are helping to pay the legal bills. The AP says one lawyer told Judge Davis Thursday it's the kind of case that could land in front of the U.S. Supreme Court.

Next Up


11 'urban explorers' face charges after being found in Fridley sewer system

A 911 caller reported seeing a group removing a manhole cover Monday night.


Man killed by St. Paul police ID'd by family, community demands answers

The man was identified as 24-year-old Howard Johnson.

Screen Shot 2022-12-07 at 7.38.02 AM

Quick shot of snow to impact morning commute in Twin Cities

Snow is moving into the metro Wednesday morning.


Body found in burned out car near Bird Island identified as local farmer

The deceased is a 59-year-old man from rural Bird Island.

Screen Shot 2022-12-06 at 2.47.44 PM

Minneapolis' Khâluna named in Eater's 2022 'Best New Restaurants'

The restaurant, opened in 2021, is known for its Laotian cuisine.

ambulance, crash

3 pedestrians struck by drivers Monday in Minnesota; 2 dead

The victims involved a 39-year-old man and two 74-year-old men.

snow, plow

Shifting storm tracks: Significant storms Friday, next week?

Sven Sundgaard has the details on an interesting forecast.

Life Link

Worker suffers serious injury in rooftop fall in rural Minnesota

The man only fell a few feet, but suffered a serious leg injury.


Judge blocks child care union vote

A Ramsey County judge on Monday issued a temporary restraining order to stop the election, which Gov. Dayton authorized last month. The judge said supporters of a union vote should draft a bill and have the Legislature decide the issue.

Dayton will challenge judge's order blocking day care union vote

The challenge comes after the attorney general's office laid out three options for the governor after a judge issued a temporary restraining order blocking a union election. Politics in Minnesota says none of the options would get the election back on track any time soon.