Skip to main content

Juror in West Fargo teacher sex case lied about past abuse, mistrial possible

  • Author:
  • Updated:

The case of a North Dakota teacher accused of having sex with a student could be heading for a mistrial after a juror holding out for a conviction was revealed to have failed to disclose she was a past victim of sexual abuse.

The West Fargo Pioneer reports that the female juror was taken to the hospital on Wednesday morning after becoming disoriented in court and told deputies that she was the "lone holdout" for a guilty verdict in the case of English teacher Aaron Knodel.

The juror told the Cass County deputies that she had been a previous victim of sexual abuse but had not told anyone, and that she did not answer a jury selection question truthfully as a result.

WDAY reports on its Facebook page that the juror indicated she was having mental issues that stemmed from her past experiences, and that "she felt the need to protect children."

Knodel, who was named the 2014 North Dakota Teacher of the Year, is on trial for five counts of felony corruption or solicitation of a minor, after being accused of having sex with one of his students in 2009, when she was 17.

The remaining 11 jurors said they had unanimously found Knodel not guilty on three of the five counts, Valley News Live reports, with the remaining two counts undecided.

As a result of the juror's removal, Judge Steven McCullough said there were grounds for a mistrial, and a prosecutor told Valley News Live that they intend to file for one, which will give the judge up to 30 days to make a decision.

The West Fargo Pioneer notes that because a verdict was only reached on three of the five counts, the prosecution can ask for a mistrial on all counts, or only on the two that remain undecided.

Next Up

Gov. Tim Walz and Scott Jensen.

Walz, Jensen clash over 'extreme' abortion views

The two clashed over the topic on Tuesday, following the Roe v. Wade decision by the U.S. Supreme Court.

Screen Shot 2022-06-28 at 12.24.27 PM

Movie filming brings memorable day for MN teen with leukemia

Ayotzin Limon-Millard was diagnosed with acute myeloid leukemia last year.

Screen Shot 2022-06-28 at 1.25.30 PM

Police trying to ID 'Playboy bandit' and 'no-pants raider' suspect

Police are calling the unidentified man "the Playboy bandit" and the "no-pants raider."

storm, severe, shelf cloud

Twin Cities under severe thunderstorm watch Tuesday afternoon

Large hail and damaging winds are the main threats.

Screen Shot 2022-06-28 at 9.27.30 AM

Famous Dave's family brings new BBQ biz to the south metro

The newest Twin Cities location is the first to offer wine slushies on the menu.

storm, shelf cloud, severe weather

Large hail possible with strong storms in eastern MN, WI

Watch the forecast update with meteorologist Sven Sundgaard.

Tony Evers, Wisconsin governor

WI governor vows to protect anyone charged with abortion crimes

“You think it’s bad now? The four Republicans that are going after me, one of them we’re going to beat, they are going to make it worse," Evers said.


Minnesota's COVID-19 update for Tuesday, June 28

The state will stop providing daily updates and move to weekly editions beginning Thursday, June 30.


Sports anchor Hobie Artigue announces FOX9 departure

Artigue has spent the past seven years covering Minnesota sports.

hennepin county medical center

Boy, 7, dies after being pulled from pool in south Minneapolis

The boy was pulled from a pool at a home in south Minneapolis.

Screen Shot 2022-06-28 at 8.32.18 AM

Nashville man leaving wedding shot in the face in Minneapolis

He was leaving a wedding when gunfire erupted near the Stone Arch Bridge Saturday night.


Abogados Café in St. Paul is the first law-themed coffee shop in America

The new business is Minnesota's first Latina-owned coffee shop.