Skip to main content

Did Schaffhausen make a 'conscious choice' or act 'as if in a dream?'

  • Author:
  • Updated:
    Original:

On day one of Aaron Schaffhausen's insanity trial jurors heard differing depictions of the man who has admitted killing his three young daughters in their River Falls, Wisc., home last summer.

His defense attorney says Schaffhausen's mental illness made him unaware of what he was doing, while prosecutors argue he made a deliberate decision to inflict pain on his ex-wife.

During opening statements Tuesday, the defense argued that Schaffhausen doesn't remember what happened when the three girls - who were 11, 8, and 5 - were stabbed to death.

"He describes it as if it's kind of a dream," Schaffhausen's attorney John Kucinski said.

Kucinski says his client had become increasingly depressed as his marriage deteriorated and before the killings he had stopped taking the antidepressants prescribed for him.

Lead prosecutor Gary Freyberg says Schaffhausen knew exactly what he was doing and made a conscious choice to kill the girls as a way to punish his ex-wife, Jessica.

Freyberg described how Schaffhausen cut the throats of the three girsl, then telephoned his wife to tell her he had killed them.

The centerpiece of the afternoon for jurors was the chilling 40-minute recording of Jessica Schaffhausen's subsequent call to 911. Dispatcher Aileen Splittgerber stayed on the phone with Schaffhausen as the mother drove from her job in St Paul to her home in River Falls.

WCCO reports Aaron Schaffhausen remained expressionless as the court listened to his ex-wife weeping, pleading, and hyperventilating on the tape.

In addition to testimony from Splittgerber, jurors heard from the babysitter who left the home when Aaron Schaffhausen arrived.

Schaffhausen pleaded guilty to the killing of 11-year-old Amara, 8-year-old Sophie and 5-year-old Cecilia last week. Now, the court is focusing on his state of mind. The jury's verdict will determine whether he is sentenced to prison or a mental institution.

Audio of Jessica Schaffhausen's 911 call is below but bear in mind its intensity may be disturbing to some listeners.

Next Up

argue-wertman booking photos

Charges: 2 teens responsible for violent carjacking spree across Twin Cities

They face a combined 31 felony counts, all tied to carjackings and related crimes.

rep nolan west mn house

MN rep. says he was 'assaulted' at activist group's public meeting

The Republican said a man grabbed his arms and yanked him from the room.

Screen Shot 2022-01-20 at 12.56.52 PM

What were the 'bizarre things' seen in Minnesota's sky?

The mysterious streaks were not UFOs and they weren't pieces of an asteroid.

icicles, freezing weather, cold weather

Booming noises in the night could be frost quakes

The loud sounds are most likely to happen during the middle of the night.

coronavirus, coronavirus test, covid-19

Free COVID testing site to open in St. Paul for 3 weeks

The federal testing site comes as demand for testing remains high.

Reyel Simmons photo 1 - complaint - crop

MN TikToker accused of faking federal agent life pleads guilty

He told his 10,000 followers he was a Homeland Security agent — authorities say it was a lie.

Wilf

Report: Vikings request second interview with 2 GM candidates

Ryan Poles of the Chiefs and Kwesi Adofo-Mensah of the Browns.

Amaya Battle

Hopkins takes on No. 1 team in the country on ESPNU Friday

The game will feature a pair of top recruits in the Class of 2022.

st. paul federation of educators - teachers

Educators in Minneapolis, St. Paul could strike amid contract negotiations

Teachers and support staff are demanding smaller class sizes, mental health support and better pay.

turtinen two harbors

MN mayor in hot water for hawking $400M underwater hotel plan

The city council called a special meeting to discuss the mayor's public comments.

police lights

Woman in critical condition after attempted murder, authorities say

A 33-year-old woman is in custody and facing possible charges.

Related