Skip to main content

Let's settle this: Who makes the best Juicy Lucy in Minnesota?

Plenty of Minnesota burger joints make Juicy Lucys that have their own devotees. Now 20 nominees want your vote for the title of best in the state.

As far as we know there's only one iconic Minnesota food that normally comes with a warning about not getting scalded by molten cheese.

Of course we're speaking of the Juicy Lucy, the cheeseburger that carries its cheese inside the burger.

Debating where to find Minnesota's best Lucy is a time-honored tradition that certainly won't stop just because of a new poll. Nonetheless, USA Today's 10Best is giving readers a chance to vote for their favorite Juicy Lucy.

Actually, 10Best has taken the liberty of narrowing the choices down to 20 nominees. You can cast a vote here once per day until the balloting stops at 11 a.m. on April 10.

A Minnesota original

10Best, which organized the competition along with Sandwich America and the Food Channel, notes that two Minneapolis spots – the 5-8 Club and Matt's Bar – each claim to have invented the Juicy Lucy.

But the popularity of this burger spread quickly and now many places have their own fans who think their preferred place makes the best ones.

You can see how the voting is shaping up on the leaderboard. Here's the list of nominees in the order of the standings on Wednesday evening:

  1. Casper & Runyon's Nook – St. Paul
  2. Matt's Bar – Minneapolis
  3. Peppers and Fries – Minneapolis
  4. Crooked Pint Ale House – multiple locations
  5. The Breeze Inn – Duluth
  6. Jersey's Bar and Grill – Inver Grove Heights
  7. B-52 Burgers and Brew – Inver Grove Heights
  8. Groveland Tap – St. Paul
  9. Blue Door Pub – St. Paul
  10. Uncle Franky's – Minneapolis
  11. 5-8 Club – Minneapolis
  12. Hell's Kitchen – Minneapolis
  13. Buffalo Tap – Savage
  14. Bennett's Chop and Railhouse – St. Paul
  15. Burger Moe's – St. Paul
  16. Newt's – Rochester
  17. The Cardinal Restaurant and Bar – Minneapolis
  18. Grumpy's Bar and Grill – Minneapolis
  19. Ray J's American Grill – Minneapolis
  20. Cadillac Ranch – Bloomington

As you can see, the nominees are dominated by Twin Cities establishments. But the inclusion of Duluth's Breeze Inn and Newt's in Rochester keeps it from being a metro-only competition.

10Best chose an iconic sandwich for every state and is in the middle of having readers vote on the best of each.

Their most recent batch of winners includes the best salmon sandwich in Washington state and the best reindeer sandwich in Alaska.

Next Up

ambulance

Man dies after being 'punched in the head' during altercation in Duluth

A 46-year-old man is in custody and facing 1st-degree manslaughter charges.

Deion Sanders

Deion Sanders says Zimmer, Spielman hadn't spoken 'in months'

Sanders' comments revealed some of the Vikings' issues last season.

police tape, crime scene

Brooklyn Park man pleads guilty in 2020 fatal drive-by shooting

Devon Manley will be sentenced to life in prison with the possibility of parole after 30 years.

Screen Shot 2020-06-16 at 7.48.35 AM

Man gets 10 years for fatal pawn shop fire during Minneapolis riots

The incident, which took place during riots in May 2020,  resulted in one man's death.

Rep. Ilhan Omar

Election officials dismiss conservative group's complaint against Rep. Ilhan Omar

The group alleged that she used campaign funds on her future husband's consulting firm.

Screen Shot 2022-01-15 at 9.53.04 AM

Reports: 6 names surface in Vikings' search for new head coach

Six names have surfaced Saturday in the Minnesota Vikings' hunt for a new head coach.

Pexels - face mask covid holding

Minnetonka approves mask mandate in emergency ordinance

The mandate officially goes into effect Monday night.

snow, measuring snow, snow totals

Here are the snow totals from Friday's winter storm in Minnesota

There was a sharp gradient around the Twin Cities, with the highest amounts in southwestern Minnesota.

Mats Zuccarello

Zuccarello scores twice, Wild win third straight

A team effort helped Minnesota dispatch the Ducks.

Rep. Tou Xiong

State lawmaker Tou Xiong apologizes after driving under the influence

The state representative was pulled over on the night of Jan. 8.

St Lukes Duluth GSV Pro

Duluth hospital requiring visitors to show vax proof, neg. test

The health care system is also tightening visitor guidelines.

ridgeview urgent care facebook

Ridgeview halting urgent care at a Twin Cities site 'until further notice'

The organization cited "growing emergency medical needs" at the facility.

Related

Let's settle this: Who makes the best Juicy Lucy in Minnesota?

Plenty of Minnesota burger joints make Juicy Lucys that have their own devotees. Now 20 nominees want your vote for the title of best in the state.

Dale Cruse FLickr Jucy Lucy Matts Bar

Chicago food critic: Juicy Lucy may be 'best cheeseburger in America'

It's the latest national praise for Minnesota's iconic burger.

Where we eat: The broasted chicken at the Brass Rail in Grandy is worth the drive

Some of Minnesota’s best restaurants are hidden in plain sight, out past the suburbs and miles off the interstate. This week, the Brass Rail in Grandy.

Where we eat: The broasted chicken at the Brass Rail in Grandy is worth the drive

Some of Minnesota’s best restaurants are hidden in plain sight, out past the suburbs and miles off the interstate. This week, the Brass Rail in Grandy.

Let's judge Food Network's list of Minnesota's 'most iconic dishes'

Wild rice soup? Absolutely. Turkey burgers? ... Sure?