Skip to main content

Little Falls case raises 'castle doctrine' questions

  • Author:
  • Updated:
    Original:

The Little Falls, Minn., case in which a man fatally shot two teens who had invaded his home has raised questions about the rights of homeowners in the use of guns to defend themselves and property.

Minnesota law allows citizens to use deadly force in self-defense, but there is no immunity for people who kill intruders in their homes, KARE 11 reports.

Saint Louis County Attorney Mark Rubin told WDIO that state law allows people to stand their ground, in their home, and approach conflict with deadly force, if necessary. That's only if the victim – and ultimately, a jury – reasonably believes the victim could be greatly harmed or killed, WDIO reports.

Earlier this year, the Minnesota Legislature debated a "castle doctrine" defense bill. The proposal was backed by gun-rights groups and opposed by Minnesota's law-enforcement organizations. It would have broadened the legal justification for citizens who use deadly force when threatened, the Star Tribune reported. But Gov. Mark Dayton vetoed the bill in May.

In Little Falls, Byron David Smith, 64, has been charged with second-degree murder. He told investigators he shot two teens as they came down the stairs to his basement on Thanksgiving Day. He said he first wounded, and then fatally shot them, according to the criminal complaint.

Morrison County authorities say Byron's actions amount to cold-blooded executions, not self-defense, the Star Tribune reports.

KARE 11 has more on how far homeowners can go to protect themselves:

Next Up

Screen Shot 2022-01-28 at 5.04.00 PM

David Arquette gives shoutout to MN's F1rst Wrestling on James Corden show

The Hollywood actor wrestled at at a F1rst Wrestling show at First Avenue in early 2019.

Best Buy - jjbers, Flickr

6 charged in Black Friday mass thefts at Twin Cities Best Buys

The group stole from three Best Buy stores that afternoon, the charges say.

Nicollet County Bell Jan 2022 4

Thieves steal large bell from rural MN church, don't get far with it

The bell was found in a ditch with tow ropes around it.

covid

COVID: More help coming to Minnesota hospitals, Walz says

More than 200 medical professionals are coming to help at short-staffed hospitals.

Screen Shot 2022-01-28 at 9.04.12 AM

Suspect arrested after falling asleep in vehicle at rest stop

The man was sleeping in a stolen vehicle in the parking lot of an I-94 rest area.

DOminos pizza flickr mr blue maumau

Charges: Edina man threatened to shoot up Domino's Pizza

He claimed a delivery driver had flipped him off, the charges say.

carvana vending machine

Carvana seeking to build vehicle vending machine in Twin Cities

The online car dealership submitted a letter of intent to buy land in the metro to build a fulfillment center.

Kwesi Adofo-Mensah

Coller: New Vikings GM Adofo-Mensah needs to be ruthless

Kwesi Adofo-Mensah needs to make some big, difficult decisions, writes Matthew Coller.

Patrick Graham

Report: Vikings to interview Giants' Patrick Graham for head coach

Graham coached with the Patriots under Bill Belichick for six years.

floor and decor screengrab

Home brand plans 'flagship' store in Maple Grove AMC Theater space

This will be the company's first Minnesota location.

covid

Minnesota's COVID-19 update for Friday, January 28

The state is still in the process of catching up with 10,000 yet-to-be processed tests.

Bryan Acuna

Twins sign 16-year-old brother of Braves star Ronald Acuna Jr.

Bryan Acuna is one of the top international prospects, according to MLB.com.

Related