Little Falls case raises 'castle doctrine' questions

Author:
Updated:
Original:

The Little Falls, Minn., case in which a man fatally shot two teens who had invaded his home has raised questions about the rights of homeowners in the use of guns to defend themselves and property.

Minnesota law allows citizens to use deadly force in self-defense, but there is no immunity for people who kill intruders in their homes, KARE 11 reports.

Saint Louis County Attorney Mark Rubin told WDIO that state law allows people to stand their ground, in their home, and approach conflict with deadly force, if necessary. That's only if the victim – and ultimately, a jury – reasonably believes the victim could be greatly harmed or killed, WDIO reports.

Earlier this year, the Minnesota Legislature debated a "castle doctrine" defense bill. The proposal was backed by gun-rights groups and opposed by Minnesota's law-enforcement organizations. It would have broadened the legal justification for citizens who use deadly force when threatened, the Star Tribune reported. But Gov. Mark Dayton vetoed the bill in May.

In Little Falls, Byron David Smith, 64, has been charged with second-degree murder. He told investigators he shot two teens as they came down the stairs to his basement on Thanksgiving Day. He said he first wounded, and then fatally shot them, according to the criminal complaint.

Morrison County authorities say Byron's actions amount to cold-blooded executions, not self-defense, the Star Tribune reports.

KARE 11 has more on how far homeowners can go to protect themselves:

Next Up

eden prairie police squad car

Carjacking reported outside shopping center in Eden Prairie

One of the suspects reportedly displayed a weapon.

court gavel

8 people charged in Medicaid fraud scheme totaling $860K

Collectively, they're charged with 46 counts of felony theft.

vaping

Minnesota gets mixed grades on its tobacco report card

In Minnesota, the economic cost due to smoking is $2.519 million with 5,910 deaths per year attributed to smoking.

Hardy Wills-Traxler

Charges: Man stabbed his father, set his home on fire

The 25-year-old has been charged with second-degree murder and first-degree arson.

Impound lot

Crowded impound lot raises COVID concerns after Minneapolis snow emergency

A vehicle owner complains about the tightly-packed impound lot following the weekend's snow.

covid-19, coronavirus

Here is Minnesota's COVID-19 update for Wednesday, Jan. 27

The latest update from the state health department.

charley's

Charges: Bar owner, employee served underage drinkers during shutdown

The bar hosted 20-30 people on Dec. 4, 2020, charges say.

police lights

Driver wearing bulletproof vest strikes pedestrian in Rochester

The 21-year-old claimed the vest keeps him warm, according to police.

Screen Shot 2019-08-19 at 8.08.05 PM

6 men charged in connection to 'disturbing trend' of carjackings, shootings

The men are accused of three carjackings in one day, as well as other crimes.

Related