Skip to main content

Man accused of killing 5-year-old Alayna Ertl pleads not guilty

The 5-year-old's body was found near a central Minnesota cabin last summer.

The man who led authorities to the body of Alayana Ertl last summer has pleaded not guilty to kidnapping, raping, and killing the 5-year-old Watkins girl. 

Zachary Todd Anderson entered his pleas in a Cass County court on Wednesday, assuring a murder trial will be happening next spring.

The 26-year-old has 19 counts against him, including kidnapping, criminal sexual conduct, and first-degree murder.

A friend of Alayna's father, Anderson had stayed at the Ertl home the night before the girl's disappearance, according to authorities. The next morning Alayna's mom discovered her gone, along with the family truck. A few hours later, an Amber Alert was issued.

Anderson's father then called authorities to tell them his son might be involved, as he had asked permission to use the family cabin near Motley, Cass County.

Police did indeed find the Ertls' stolen truck in a ravine near the cabin, and shortly thereafter Anderson himself, standing knee-deep in swamp water. He was arrested, and eventually pointed police in the direction of Alayna's body, the charges say. 

They soon found the girl's naked body, and medical examiners subsequently determined she'd been strangled, bludgeoned, and sexually assaulted, with signs of penetration, according to the charges.

What happens next

Anderson continues to be held in custody in the Crow Wing County jail.

His "not guilty" pleas mean the case is headed to trial, but prosecutors are already facing some obstacles.

According to the St. Cloud Times, Anderson's lawyers have asked the presiding judge to suppress most of the incriminating evidence against him – and to rule his initial statements to police inadmissible in court – on the grounds that "investigators improperly questioned Anderson."

The paper says the trial is scheduled to begin in April 2018, and expected to last three weeks. 

GoMN has reached out to the Cass County attorney for comment. 

Next Up

St. Louis County

St. Louis County set to declare state of emergency ahead of peak flood levels

Volunteers are urgently needed for sandbagging efforts in a small community near Voyageurs National Park.

Screen Shot 2022-05-16 at 5.03.30 PM

Brothers Bar & Grill closes in downtown Minneapolis

The Midwest chain closed its St. Cloud location in 2018.

Ken Jeong

Licensed physician Ken Jeong to do standup in MN this September

The licensed physician will take the stage at Treasure Island Resort and Casino on Sept. 30.

Osseo Police Department

Osseo PD says officer did not pursue suspect who caused fatal crash

The crash happened in Brooklyn Park early Sunday morning.

221 Main Street. E. Albert Lea

Suspect arrested after 3 family members stabbed in Albert Lea

The three victims are related, according to police.


Evidence that omicron strains BA.4 and BA.5 are in Minnesota

The European CDC has warned of a possible significant summer surge fueled by the omicron subvariants.

driving unsplash - crop

Hastings man charged for driving drunk with 2-year-old in vehicle

Matthew Quade's BAC was almost five times over the legal limit when police pulled him over last week.

police lights

Arrest made after person shot at Hopkins apartment building

Police say this was an isolated incident and that the victim and suspect knew each other.


BA.2.12.1 omicron subvariant quickly becoming dominant in MN

Experts say the subvariant is more transmissible but there is not evidence to suggest it causes more severe disease.


The man charged with killing 5-year-old Alayna Ertl is now facing a life sentence

The 5-year-old's disappearance in August led to an Amber Alert and hourslong search.

5-year-old Alayna Ertl died of 'homicidal violence,' body found in 'swampy area'

The 5-year-old girl killed following an abduction and Amber Alert died of "homicidal violence," a medical examiner says.

Family friend gets life without parole for killing of 5-year-old Alayna Ertl

Zachary Anderson was a friend of the 5 year old's father.

Man charged with sexual assault, murder in death of 5-year-old Alayna Ertl

Zachary Todd Anderson was charged Tuesday in connection with the death of Alayna Ertl.

Arthur Kollie

Man pleads guilty to brutal murder of 14-year-old girl in Fargo

The 14-year-old girl was the victim of a random attack outside a Fargo strip mall.

Charges: Hibbing trio blindfolded, killed victim in the woods

The 33-year-old victim's body was found near a snowmobile trail.