Skip to main content

Man sentenced to life for 'unspeakably evil' Oak Park Heights murder

  • Author:
  • Updated:

A Stillwater man will spend the rest of his life in prison after being sentenced for an "unspeakably evil" killing of a vulnerable man in Oak Park Heights.

KSTP reports Nathan Nigel Anthony Eldredge, 25, was sentenced Thursday to life without parole after being convicted of two counts of second-degree murder over the killing of Nils Johnson.

The 39-year-old's body was found by police at his condominium last April, with his hands bound and a plastic bag covering his head and taped around his neck, the TV station notes.

Johnson's mother Diane said her son developed a mental illness in high school, saying she warned him people could take advantage of him. She described his murder as "unspeakably evil."

The Star Tribune reports Eldredge represented himself in court and was "silent and unmoving" as his sentence was read out – as he had been throughout the three-day trial.

He pleaded not guilty but did not defend himself against the charges, which states he beat Johnson with a police baton before suffocating him with plastic bags.

"It really is two lives lost," Diane Johnson told the Pioneer Press said after the trial. "Nathan is dead, for all practical purposes. Just as dead as my son. It’s just totally senseless. A tragedy all around."

Next Up


Ringo Starr's late cancellation of MN show was because he has COVID-19

The Beatles drummer was due to perform in Minnesota Sunday.

Screen Shot 2022-10-03 at 4.32.58 PM

Fire destroys cafe, two other business properties in downtown Fairfax

A former pizza joint was also destroyed, while two other properties were damaged.

Hennepin County Medical Center, HCMC

Woman dies from injuries in crash that killed her husband, another man

The couple in their 80s died in the collision near Lake Lillian.

CPAP masks

2 Park Nicollet employees convicted of embezzling $500,000

The pair worked at a CPAP clinic in St. Louis Park.


No Jingle Ball this year? Twin Cities left off iHeartRadio holiday tour

The annual touring event usually visits the Xcel Energy Center.

Target store

Target gives first look at some of its Deal Days discounts

The Minneapolis retailer is holding its Deal Days event earlier than ever, in an attempt to drive sales after a turbulent year.

Screen Shot 2022-10-03 at 11.03.12 AM

Man dies after crashing truck into western Wisconsin lake

The victim was unable to make it to shore despite being able to get out of his truck.

ATV, all-terrain vehicle

Sheriff: Man who didn't return to campsite died in ATV crash

It happened at the Foothills State Forest and Spider Lake ATV Recreation Area

Richard Liu, aka Liu Qiangdong

Chinese billionaire settles lawsuit over alleged rape in Minneapolis

The tech billionaire was accused of sexually assaulting a University of Minnesota student in 2018.

US Navy Flickr - COVID hospital PPE nurse

Frontline worker payments: Over a million Minnesotans to get $487.45

Gov. Tim Walz says the payments will start going out on Wednesday.


Ed Sheeran to bring North America stadium tour to Minneapolis

It's the second show announced for the Vikings stadium in 2023.


Man sentenced to life for murdering teen in Minneapolis park

18-year-old George Pineda was killed last June.