Updated:
Original:

Minn. Supreme Court on DWI case: If consent is given, no warrant is needed

Author:

The Minnesota Supreme Court says police do not need to obtain a search warrant to draw blood, breath and urine of suspected drunk drivers if consent is given.

The state's high court issued the decision in State v. Brooks Wednesday morning.

The case stems from a consolidation of three DWI cases, two in Scott County and one in Hennepin County, over a 6-month period in 2009 and 2010 involving Wesley Eugene Brooks, 40, of Prior Lake.

During all three arrests, Brooks consented to either urine or blood tests, but later argued he was coerced. Brooks' attorney argued that a DWI stop alone is not reason to take someone’s blood, breath or urine without consent and doing so is a violation of their constitutional rights.

Chief Justice Lori Gildea said in the court opinion that since Brooks consented to the blood-alcohol tests, a warrant was unnecessary.

In each case, police read Brooks the "implied consent advisory," which informs drivers that Minnesota law requires them to take a chemical test for the presence of alcohol, that refusing to take a test is a crime and that drivers have the right to talk to a lawyer before deciding whether to take a test.

Police also provided Brooks a phone to call his attorney during the arrests before he eventually agreed to testing.

"Minnesota’s implied consent law, even though it makes it a crime to refuse testing, also does not coerce a driver into testifying against himself," Gildea wrote.

Next Up

Proctor football

Proctor football investigation: Case goes to county attorney

The office will review the evidence and consider possible criminal charges.

kirsten mitchell screegrab

'I’m heading home!': CA reporter announces return to WCCO

Kirsten Mitchell interned at WCCO years ago. Now, she's coming back as a reporter.

eggs

As part of price gouging settlement, farm to donate 1M eggs to food nonprofits

The egg producer will donate more than 1 million eggs to nonprofits fighting hunger.

plane, Piper PA-32

Sheriff: Witnesses saw plane 'performing aerial maneuvers' before fatal crash

The single-engine aircraft went down in northern Wisconsin, killing a brother and sister.

Screen Shot 2021-10-25 at 8.51.02 AM

Community rallies around Minnetonka HS dancer battling brain tumor

A fundraiser raised more than $44,000 of its $60,000 goal in the first two days.

twin city gardens

In rare move, MDH takes control of Minneapolis nursing home

The temporary receivership is to ensure resident safety.

Sen Mark Koran crop

Lawmaker deletes post encouraging donations to family charged in Capitol riot

Sen. Mark Koran, in his Facebook post, described them as "a good family!"

Screen Shot 2021-05-27 at 11.04.26 AM

Mother charged with beating daughter to death ruled incompetent

The case against the Woodbury woman will be put "indeterminately suspended."

msp airport

Employers at MSP Airport seeking to hire 700-plus workers

Employers include restaurants, retail, hotel, airlines and security.

Related