Skip to main content

Minneapolis settles police custody death lawsuit for $3M

  • Author:
  • Updated:

A $3 million settlement has been reached between the City of Minneapolis and the family of a man who died after a police altercation in September of 2010, the Pioneer Press reports.

The family of David Smith will receive $1.1 million in the settlement of the police misconduct suit, and the Smith family's attorney, Gaskins Bennett Birrell & Schupp, will receive $1.975 million in fees.

The 28-year-old Smith died about a week after an altercation at the downtown Minneapolis YMCA. Smith was Tased by officers who then placed him on his stomach and put their knees on his back to restrain him, the paper says.

Former Minneapolis Police Chief Tim Dolan maintains the two officers who restrained Smith appeared to have used proper protocols and procedures.

According to the Star Tribune, the Hennepin County Medical Examiner ruled Smith's death a homicide.

Minneapolis City Attorney Susan Segal called the settlement the "responsible way to bring this to a close in the face of mounting legal costs that would continue to grow significantly through a trial."

Meanwhile, Minneapolis Police Chief Janee Harteau expressed sympathy to Smith's family, but noted that it's an "unfortunate reality" that "in any situation where police must restrain someone, there can be unintended results."

Next Up


Stevens County may have been hit the hardest by Thursday storms

The entire county was without power after the storms blew through Thursday evening.

State Patrol

3 killed, 1 critical after trio of crashes in Minnesota Thursday

One person also faces life-threatening injuries in a crash that happened in Olmsted County.

Screen Shot 2022-05-13 at 1.25.08 PM

Mora woman saves pelican caught in fishing line for days

A birthday fishing trip shapes into a heroic tale.

Kelsey Peterson in the documentary, "Move Me."

Doc depicting MN dancer's journey with paralysis debuts at Twin Cities film festival

The film surrounds St. Paul-born Kelsey Peterson, who continues to pursue her passions in dance after being paralyzed from the chest down in 2012.

Milwaukee Ave

Gallery: Rare opportunity to own a home on historic Milwaukee Avenue

All the houses on the avenue front onto a pedestrian mall in south Minneapolis.

US Secretary of Defense COVID vaccine flickr

Minnesota's COVID-19 update for Friday, May 13

The next update will be provided Monday.


Minnesota part of the top 2 hurricane force wind events since 2004

Photo above shows the ominous view in Marshall, Minnesota as a dangerous line of storms approached Thursday afternoon.

Screen Shot 2022-05-13 at 9.24.48 AM

DFL efforts to pass abortion, reproductive health bills blocked in Senate

The push to pass a slate of abortion and healthcare-related bills comes after a leaked Supreme Court opinion draft indicated Roe v Wade will be overturned.

Screen Shot 2022-05-13 at 8.16.56 AM

Teen pulled from St. Croix River Thursday dies

The teen was located around 40 minutes after he had gone under water.

Screen Shot 2022-05-13 at 7.23.52 AM

Thursday performances of Runestone! canceled due to COVID cases

This weekend's performances are still going ahead, History Theatre says.

Screen Shot 2022-05-12 at 7.12.27 PM

Storms cause grain bin to fall, killing one in Kandiyohi County

The National Weather Service confirmed the death on Thursday evening.


Jury settles Minneapolis officer's snooping lawsuit for $585K

Amy Krekelberg filed the suit after her fellow officers illegally accessed her personal data.

3M settles lawsuit over Cogent purchase

Both 3M and Cogent deny any wrong doing, but have agreed to pay $1.9 million to shareholders and their attorneys. Bloomberg reports the investors claim Cogent CEO Ming Hsieh favored 3M to collect a retention bonus. The Maplewood-based company paid about $943 million in 2010 for Cogent.