Minn. Court of Appeals: Law against 'advising' suicides is unconstitutional


The Minnesota Court of Appeals says the state law against "advising" suicides is an overly broad restriction on free speech, the Associated Press reports.

The three-judge panel affirmed Dakota County Judge Karen Asphaug's March ruling that the language of the Minnesota statute is unconstitutional. Dakota County prosecutors had appealed her declaration.

The ruling stems from a case where 57-year-old Doreen Dunn of Apple Valley sought out Final Exit Network, Inc., a national right-to-die group, to consult the organization on taking her own life.

Dunn, who suffered from chronic illness for more than a decade, was found dead by her husband at their home on May 30, 2007. Initial autopsy results determined Dunn had died from natural causes.

It wasn't until about two years later that the Dakota County Attorney's Office learned that Final Exit had assisted Dunn in a suicide.

Dunn had allegedly placed a device called a "helium hood" -- a plastic bag attached to a helium tank -- over her head to end her life.

The Georgia-based nonprofit provides counseling and other services to people suffering from irreversible medical conditions who are considering ending their lives.

"We are very careful not to encourage anybody to end their life," Frank Kavanaugh, Final Exit board member, told KSTP in a May report. "We never provide the means for them to do so and we don't physically assist in any way. All we do is provide information, and we think in doing that we are protected by our First Amendment right of free speech."

According to the Dakota County Attorney's Office, "Exit Guides" from the organization are typically present at the time of a suicide and leave after it's complete, taking with them all the evidence that a suicide has occurred.

A grand jury indicted Final Exit and four of its members, including two who were allegedly present at the time of the suicide, on charges of assisting another to commit suicide and interference with a death scene.

Asphaug previously dismissed a felony charge against the founder of Final Exit and former president Ted Goodwin.

The Associated Press says the appellate court's decision sends the case back to Dakota County District Court for further proceedings against the group and its accused members.

Dakota County Attorney Jim Backstrom says he plans to ask the Minnesota Supreme Court to review the state Court of Appeals ruling.

Next Up

storm, severe weather

'Particularly dangerous situation' issued by NWS as potential derecho nears

Storms could produce damaging winds, large hail and tornadoes.

Flickr - Minnesota state senate chamber - Matt Lewis

Calls for investigation after former DFL staffer details sexual harassment

Cynthia Callais provided her account to the Minnesota Reformer.

Motzko and Schuneman

Driver in Orono crash that killed Motzko, Schuneman is in custody

The 51-year-old reportedly turned himself into police Wednesday.

Miguel Sano

Twins smash 7 homers, still lose to Tigers

It was a wild afternoon at Target Field.

Pixabay - school - classroom

Decision on school mask mandates will be up to local districts

It will not come from the health or education departments, an official said Wednesday.

spices recall

McCormick recalling some spice mixes sold in Minnesota

The company issued the voluntary recall over possible salmonella risk.

the mayo clinic - edit

Mayo Clinic named No. 1 on 'Best Hospitals' list

It's the sixth year in a row the Rochester hospital has been named the best of the best.

36262 Ottertail Rd, Battle Lake, Minnesota - September 2009

Bystander on dock sees teen struggling in water, jumps in to save him

The teen kept going under the surface near a dam on Otter Tail Lake.

castaway club camp

Cluster of COVID-19 cases tied to camp in western Minnesota

Ten cases have been reported among staff, report states.

Screen Shot 2021-07-28 at 12.16.13 PM

Rodgers pummels Packers front office in viral press conference

"The rules are the same for most people, but every now and then there are some outliers."

Pexels - mother child mask covid

MDH urging that all wear face masks, 12+ get vaccinated for upcoming school year

State health officials revealed their COVID-19 recommendations for 2021-22.

sunfish 1

Gallery: Aspen-inspired estate on private lake is yours for $4.95M

Each bedroom has its own bathroom. And there are four laundry rooms.


Minn. Supreme Court to hear appeal in ex-nurse's suicide aiding case

The Minnesota Supreme Court will hear the appeal of a former nurse convicted of encouraging suicide in online chatrooms. Fifty-year-old William Melchert-Dinkel of Faribault was convicted of two counts of aiding suicide in the deaths of 32-year-old Mark Drybrough, of Coventry, England, who hanged himself in 2005; and 18-year-old Nadia Kajouji, of Brampton, Ontario, who jumped into a frozen river in 2008.