MN Supreme Court: Dayton had a right to defund the Legislature

The GOP-led Legislature sued Dayton for vetoing their operating budget.

The Minnesota Supreme Court has reached a decision on that Republican-led lawsuit against Gov. Mark Dayton. 

In short, the court says Dayton does indeed have the constitutional power to defund the state Legislature.

The governor did this earlier in the year by vetoing the part of the 2018 budget that keeps the Legislature running (and its staff members paid). 

It was a tactic to force lawmakers to redo parts of that budget – with which Dayton and his fellow DFLers were unhappy. But the Republicans-led Legislature ended up suing the governor instead, saying the move was a constitutional overreach.

On Friday though the state Supreme Court sided with Dayton, saying in part, "We hold that the Governor's exercise of his of his line-item veto power over the appropriation for the Legislature's biennial budget" was constitutional.

In other words, yes, he can do that. 

Dayton in an email statement said he's "very pleased" his actions were upheld.

Though Friday's ruling overturned an earlier decision by an appeals court, it isn't a full-fledged victory for Dayton. It also orders both him and his Republican rivals to sort out their budget differences. And the clock is ticking.

"We therefore require both parties to participate in good faith efforts to resolve this dispute through mediation," says the court's ruling. Both sides have until Tuesday, Sept. 12, to pick a mediator. 

If not, the court writes, one will be picked for them.

Dayton in his statement said he's also pleased with that piece of the ruling however, adding he proposed such negotiations months ago.

"I remain ready and very willing to engage in those negotiations immediately," he said. "I have asked my legal team to contact their legislative counterparts to begin to resolve this matter."

As MinnPost noted earlier this year, Dayton's veto created "an unusual situation," because "no Minnesota governor has ever vetoed the entire budget of the legislative branch before."

The site also predicted that "any ruling in the case could set legal precedent for governors and legislatures for decades to come." 

(Note: This story's language has been updated to make it clear the Legislature, which is led by Republicans, filed the lawsuit against the governor.)

Next Up

State Capitol.

Minnesota Republicans looking to make PPP loans exempt from state taxes

Congress made PPP loans exempt from federal taxes late last year.

kate knuth

Former DFL state Rep. Knuth announces run for Minneapolis mayor

She is among those challenging Mayor Frey in November.

Screen Shot 2021-03-02 at 10.27.17 AM

Fox Sports North adds Gigi Marvin to Wild broadcast team

Marvin is three-time Olympic medal winner and former Warroad prep hockey star.

police lights

Wisconsin father suspected of killing his 6-week-old son

The father was arrested Monday in connection to the infant's Feb. 19 death.


Minnesota saw record gun permit applications in 2020

The trend in Minnesota aligns with national spikes.


St. Paul police ask for help solving 2 hit-and-run cases

A man is still hospitalized after being hit by a car in mid-February, while a woman is on a "long road to recovery" after being hit by a van in December.

duluth ship fire

Duluth fire crews battle blaze on 118-year-old lake freighter

The J.B. Ford, which is the oldest intact lake freighter still floating, has been housed at a scrapyard since 2015.


Target sales grew by $15B in 2020, more than past 11 years combined

The pandemic led to a historic year for the Minneapolis retailer.


Eagan-based Villaume Industries pays $90K fine in gender discrimination case

After the Minnesota Department of Human Rights found the company refused to hire women, Villaume committed to reforms


11 more people charged in massive magazine scam plead guilty

In total, 63 people from across the U.S. were charged in what prosecutors called the "largest elder fraud scheme in the nation."


Supreme Court backs Gov. Dayton's defunding of Minnesota Legislature

The court ruled against the Republican-led Legislature.

Livestreaming soon: The Minnesota Supreme Court

It'll start with a GOP lawsuit against Gov. Dayton.

Peace and harmony between Dayton and the new Legislature? Uh, no

The governor says leaders in Minnesota's divided government will have to work together. But don't expect them to hold hands and sway.

MN lawmakers pass budget in overnight special session

The House and the Senate had to burn the midnight oil to hammer out the $48 billion spending bill.

MN Supreme Court rejects voter's effort to change GOP ballot

The Lake Elmo Republican had sued because President Trump is the only name on the ballot.

Sen. McCain stirs Supreme Court pot with vow to keep fighting nominees

John McCain says Republicans will unite "against any Supreme Court nominee" Hillary Clinton might put forward.

Dayton's approval rating dominates Legislature

A KSTP/Survey USA poll shows only 17 percent of Minnesotans surveyed approved of the GOP-controlled Legislature, while 65 percent disapprove the job of lawmakers at the state Capitol. The same poll gives Dayton an approval rating of 50 percent, while 33 percent don't approve of the governor.

vote, vote now

MN Supreme Court dismisses attempt to block election certification

Another legal defeat for Republicans challenging the election.