Skip to main content

MN Supreme Court says remorse shouldn't shorten prison sentences

  • Author:
  • Updated:

A man convicted of sexually assaulting a friend will not have his sentenced reduced due to his remorse, the Minnesota Supreme Court decided in a ruling this week.

Jacob Miles Solberg was convicted of sexually assaulting a woman in 2014. Under Minnesota Sentencing Guidelines, Solberg's should have been imprisoned for 53 to 74 months.

However, he was only sentenced for 30 months, due to his remorse.

The state Court of Appeals reversed his sentencing. Solberg then petitioned for a review, arguing his remorse was the single factor and that was sufficient for a reduced sentence.

State law does allow for a shortened sentence based on one factor, but the Supreme Court affirmed the Court of Appeals' decision that reversed Solberg's sentence.

“A defendant’s remorse generally does not bear on a decision to reduce the length of a sentence,” Justice Margaret Chutich wrote in the opinion.

The crime

According to the Supreme Court's opinion:

In early June 2013, Solberg told the victim, a friend, after a street dance that friends were coming to his house and she should join him.

She agreed, but when she arrived no one else was present.

After they started watching television, Solberg kept begging the victim to have sex with him even though she said no multiple times.

The victim asked Solberg to drive her back to her truck, but instead he pushed her back onto the couch, held her down and raped her.

Solberg told her “it’s OK” because “my doctor said I can’t have kids” and “undefinedt’s not cheating if [our significant others] don’t find out.”

Solberg later admitted he “might’ve pressured her into it” but thought she was playing “hard to get.”

The ruling

Solberg was charged with third-degree criminal sexual conduct and pleaded not guilty.

In his appeal, Solberg cited a psychosexual assessment which said Solberg "acknowledged experiencing feelings [of] guilt at a clinically significant level."

At the sentencing hearing Solberg also said: "I know what I've done was wrong and it's been on me every single day. If there was anything I could do to make it better, I would ... I just wish I could go back in time and change what happened."

The Court of Appeals expressed doubt that Solberg’s remorse was genuine, since he both claimed to having no memory of the offense due to alcohol as well as not entering a plea until the trial was well underway.

In her opinion, Chutich said even if his regret was genuine, the district court did not find that it made his conduct any less serious.

"A durational departure must be based on factors that reflect the seriousness of the offense, not the characteristics of the offender," Chutich said. "In other words, unless a defendant can show that his demonstrated remorse is directly related to the criminal conduct at issue and made that conduct significantly less serious than the typical conduct underlying the offense of conviction, remorse cannot justify a downward durational departure."

Next Up

Screen Shot 2022-05-25 at 8.01.45 AM

6-year-old and his grandparents killed in trailer home fire

"Found among the charred debris were two adults and a child," the sheriff's office said in a release.


Uvalde massacre: MN schools react with horror, increase security

A gunman killed 19 children and two adults in Texas Tuesday afternoon.

Screen Shot 2022-05-24 at 5.21.04 PM

Ex-South St. Paul coach dies by suicide 2 days before sentencing

Matthew McCollister was to be sentenced for fraud in federal court on Wednesday.


Minnesota 'glampground' named one of 10 best in U.S.

In Nevis, Minnesota, campers can stay in a refurbished 1905 train car.

Screen Shot 2022-01-28 at 9.04.12 AM

Two men charged over terrifying armed robbery at Newport apartment

They shot the woman who lives in the apartment in the abdomen, and put a gun to a man's head.

Minneapolis police

Minneapolis 2-year-old identified in suspicious death case

The cause of death has not yet been revealed due to an ongoing investigation.

Arianna Vos

Victim of wrong-way driver crash ID'd as Hutchinson 19-year-old

Three women, ages 19, 20 and 20, were in the vehicle struck by a wrong-way driver early Sunday morning.

Julissa Thaler

Eli Hart killing: Police investigating multiple crime scenes

An announcement Tuesday confirmed potential crime scenes in Mound and Minnetrista.

SEIU Healthcare Minnesota strike.

Twin Cities mental health workers gather for 1-day strike

More than 400 mental health workers are participating in the unionized strike on Tuesday.

Bloomington Fire

HAZMAT team at Bloomington hotel following chemical spill in pool

The fire department said two hotel employees are being evaluated by paramedics.

Screen Shot 2022-03-24 at 9.21.32 AM

Big Brothers Big Sisters Twin Cities gets $6M of Mackenzie Scott donation

The donation is the largest the organization has ever seen from a single individual.


MN Supreme Court: Gauthier removed from ballot

Disgraced Duluth lawmaker Rep. Kerry Gauthier won't appear on the ballot, the Minnesota Supreme Court ruled Tuesday. The high court granted the Democratic Party's request to have Gauthier's name scrubbed and replaced by endorsed candidate Erik Simonson.