Skip to main content

New Brighton man convicted of killing his neighbor admits he lied, gets life in prison

  • Author:
  • Updated:
    Original:

Before a New Brighton man convicted of fatally shooting his neighbor following a years-long dispute was sentenced to life in prison without parole, he apologized and admitted he lied during his trial.

Neil Zumberge was found guilty last month in the May 5, 2014, shooting death of his New Brighton neighbor, 46-year-old Todd Stevens. He also injured Stevens' girlfriend, Jennifer Damerow-Cleven, 49, in the shooting.

In addition to the life sentence, Judge Margaret Marrinan sentenced Zumberge to serve 15 years in prison for the attempted first-degree murder charge, which will be served consecutively with his life sentence, the Star Tribune says.

Zumberge had admitted to the shooting, but claimed self defense during his trial, while prosecutors said Zumberge had a grudge against Stevens because of previous disputes, including how he feed deer in his yard.

At Wednesday's sentencing hearing, Zumberge apologized and also said he lied on the witness stand about some facts involving the shooting, telling the court he was "coached."

"I'd like to tell the truth and possibly start the healing process and make peace with God. The victim's family is entitled to this," Zumberge told the court, according to the Pioneer Press.

"The shooting didn't happen like I said, that the gun kept going off," Zumberge said, the newspaper notes. "That's not true. That I saw him reaching for his cellphone which I thought was a gun, that's really not the truth. That was the result of coaching I received."

He also said he didn't intend to shoot Damerow-Cleven, the Pioneer Press says.

He also apologized in a jailhouse interview with the Star Tribune on Tuesday, saying: “I’m sorry for his family and my family, and all the hurt that I’ve caused. It was my fault, too. I was being pigheaded.”

Zumberge plans to appeal his life sentence. FOX 9 says Zumberge has also made it clear that he wants to fire his attorney because he didn't feel he got the representation he needed.

Next Up

polley freeborn county jail roster jan 2022 resize

Charges: MN high school counselor sexually assaulted student

The 16-year-old victim had regularly gone to him for academic help and other support, authorities say.

Proctor football

Proctor investigation: Senior charged with sexually assaulting teammate

The criminal charges come after a monthslong review of the allegations.

Screen Shot 2020-04-28 at 9.07.41 PM

Ordway will require vaccinated audience members also be boosted

If someone has not gotten a booster shot, they will have to show a negative COVID test.

Gophers basketball, Williams Arena, Gopher fans

U of M to require vaccine or negative test proof for large events

The policy doesn't go into effect until late-January.

Lauri Anne Deatherage

Man indicted for first-degree murder in ex-wife's death

He's accused of killing her days after she remarried.

Jackknifed semi I-94 Sauk Centre Jesse Grabow

Crashes, spinouts piling up as snow blankets southern MN

Snow is expected to continue throughout the day.

covid

Minnesota's COVID-19 update for Friday, January 14

More than 11,000 cases for a second day in a row.

Juicy Lucy at Matt's Bar

Mashed.com's choice for MN's best sandwich? A famous burger

Is the Juicy Lucy great? Yes. But we can't help but think some sandwiches may have been overlooked.

Boundary Waters BWCAW 1

Boundary Waters permits available next week, but there won't be as many

The number available this year have been cut after increased visitation that's led to congestion and damage to natural resources.

Screen Shot 2022-01-14 at 9.52.35 AM

Four arrested after attempted carjacking at Moorhead gas station

The incident occurred at around 3:40 p.m. at the Travel Mart in Moorhead.

Related