Skip to main content

New Republic examines Mayo's deal with state, influence on Rochester

  • Author:
  • Updated:

Is there much difference between the Minnesota Vikings ploy to get public funding for a new stadium and that of the Mayo Clinic's similar deal for state money to expand its Rochester campus?

Not really, according to a new piece in the New Republic, called "Held Hostage by a Hospital."

That tells you about all you need to know about the angle of the story, but there are still points worth considering in view of the past Minnesota legislative session, in which lawmakers approved $585 million to go to Mayo.

For instance, the magazine notes that both the Vikings and Mayo implicitly threatened a move elsewhere, noting the quip of John Noseworthy, the president and CEO of Mayo, from last April that “there are 49 states that would like us to invest in them. That’s the truth.”

More troubling to writer Ilan Greenberg is the notion that Mayo wants to be the premiere medical destination in the nation, with the city outshining as Boulder, Colo., Madison, Wis., or even Bangkok or Singapore.

"In order to accomplish this, though, Mayo has decided that Rochester, population 108,000, needs to double in size," Greenberg argues.

“The Mayo Clinic as an entity is a five-star experience," says one Mayo director. "We want Rochester to be able to offer the same. We need more options.”

Whether this gambit is good for Mayo is unquestioned, but what about Rochester?

The market for medical destination is in the $60 billion range and growing at a 35 percent clip,, according to a 2009 study by DeLoitte and Touche. For Mayo to get a bigger slice of that market, the city of Rochester must step up, the clinic seems to be saying.

As Politics in Minnesota notes, Greenberg argues that it will take high-end bars and restaurants, theater, an expanded University of Minnesota campus and other cultural upgrade to attract the right patients and doctors to the facility - and the city.

Next Up

Screen Shot 2022-09-25 at 6.09.38 PM

Parkland shooting survivor David Hogg to headline Duluth rally

The rally will take place at Leif Erikson Park on Oct. 1.

Screen Shot 2022-09-26 at 6.09.43 AM

Stella's Fish Cafe closes temporarily to investigate viral rodent video

The Uptown restaurant said it was closing temporarily so it could investigate the claims.

Governor Tim Walz

Walz, judge in dispute over Feeding Our Future case

A Ramsey County judge disputed Walz's claims that the Minnesota Department of Education was ordered by the court to resume payments to Feeding Our Future.


2 dead, 1 with life-threatening injuries in Hwy. 7 crash

Both drivers were not wearing their seatbelt, according to the State Patrol.

Screen Shot 2022-09-25 at 11.50.33 AM

15-year-old Richfield football game shooting suspect arrested

A 16-year-old accused of instigating the altercation is also in custody.

Police tape

3 arrested after homicide, burglary in Inver Grove Heights

Charges of first-degree murder and first-degree burglary are pending.

fire, firefighter

Woman dies after becoming trapped in Waseca house fire

Police tried to enter the home but heavy smoke prevented them from getting inside.


1 dead, 2 with life-threatening injuries in Minnesota crash

The crash happened just after 7:30 p.m. Friday.

Image (1)

School bus carrying students plunges into river southwest of Fargo

None of the kids suffered life-threatening injuries, though some were taken to area hospitals.

Richfield High School

Richfield High School cancels weekend events after shooting

Two men were shot outside the school's football stadium

Screen Shot 2022-09-23 at 10.21.38 PM

Sound of shots, mass panic at Richfield football game streamed live on YouTube

Gunfire caused panic at a varsity football game Friday night.