Skip to main content

No charges in confrontation that left college student with horrific injuries

Isaiah Smith suffered brutal injuries, but accounts of the confrontation complicate things.

Despite the horrific injuries they left him with, the people who got into an altercation with an NDSU student earlier this month will not be charged.

Isaiah Smith's story prompted an outpouring of support on social media, with family members reporting the 21-year-old was beaten because he had confronted an alleged domestic abuser at a Fargo house party.

The attack left his jaw "hanging from his face" and "broken in three places," among other grievous injuries.

But this week, prosecutors in Cass County, North Dakota, announced they would not be filing any criminal charges in the incident. 

It's because "accounts from the scene tend to show Smith was the aggressor," the Forum reported

And because state law allows someone to use physical force to defend another person, there's no way to prove assault, said the prosecutor's report detailed by the Forum.

The decision is not sitting well with Smith's family. 

"Everyone is nitpicking what happened," his sister Casey Droher said in an update on their YouCaring fundraising page. Though she admitted "choice words" were exchanged between her brother and his rival, and that alcohol was involved on both sides.

"While they were arguing," she continued, "the guys [sic] friend grabbed Isaiah from behind the neck, choking him, and slamming him to the ground." 

She also says the assailants later explained it all as an attempt to defend their friend, and that "investigators are basing their decision off of what the men are saying happened." 

"We do not know the full truth, we do know however that several doctors who have examined Isaiahs [sic] injuries, believe this story is inconsistent with what his injuries look like," she added.

Smith's recovery

"Isaiah is okay" and "going through the motions of recovering," Droher wrote in the same update. 

She said the wires have been removed from his jaw, but he will have to keep to a "soup/smoothie diet" for another six to eight weeks, and possibly longer. 

Smith, from Brainerd, is apparently also having trouble remembering exactly what happened during the attack because of the concussion he suffered. 

The fundraising page has garnered over $42,000, surpassing the goal by a couple thousand dollars. 

Smith is a nursing student at North Dakota State University.

Next Up

Screen Shot 2022-08-18 at 8.10.56 AM

Restrictions in place as Emerald Ash Borer found in Sherburne County

The county is now the 36th in the state with a confirmed presence of the invasive insect.

Fire, firefighters

Home that was scene of June standoff engulfed in fire

Authorities arrived to find the home fully ablaze.

Rosland park bridge

Crosstown Hwy. 62 reopens as footage emerges of truck hitting bridge

The westbound lanes were closed in Edina from Tuesday afternoon to Wednesday night.

Screen Shot 2022-08-17 at 8.31.42 PM

Flash flooding as torrential rain hammers Cambridge

Flooding and damage from a non-severe storm Wednesday evening.

Screen Shot 2022-08-17 at 4.02.18 PM

Minneapolis nonprofit celebrates anonymous donor's $1.5M gift

Appetite For Change is building sustainable, local food systems in North Minneapolis.

police lights

On the lam since 2007, suspect in MN murder case arrested in Florida

The suspect is one of three men connected to a fatal drive-by shooting on St. Paul's West Side.

Deer on road

Motorcyclist in collision with deer dies from injuries

The 55-year-old from Princeton died at a hospital a day after the crash.


Burnsville approves measure that will make its landfill much taller

The expansion will increase the landfill's allowable height by an additional 268 feet.

michael carbo

Northern MN man found guilty in 1980s cold case murder

Nancy Daugherty was found dead in the afternoon hours of July 16, 1986.

Red Ox Cafe

Breakfast spot in Ham Lake closes after decades in business

The business posted an announcement on its front door.

Screen Shot 2022-08-17 at 1.43.04 PM

St. Paul man killed partner, himself while their 5 kids were home

St. Paul confirmed the double shooting on Tuesday evening was murder-suicide.

Kids competing in USA Mullet Championships

Minnesota, Wisconsin kids competing in USA Mullet Championships

The contest is divided into kids and teens divisions.


Nursing student from Minnesota maimed in vicious beating

"His jaw was hanging from his face, broken in three places."

Charges filed in vicious attack on elderly Metro Transit bus rider

The victim suffered a serious brain injury and "may not survive."

Another five MN corrections officers injured in prison attacks

The two incidents are part of a recent pattern of violence against Minnesota prison staff.

Gathering at Dar Al-Farooq Islamic Center in Bloomington

MN faith leaders gather in support of Muslim community following attack

A Twin Cities imam was assaulted earlier this month.

Charges: Student punched college instructor unconscious

The female instructor suffered two broken bones in her face.

Target in Savage, MN

Teen found shot in the head outside Target in Savage, MN

The assault happened in the parking lot on Friday evening.

Matt Belanger

Man charged in light rail station attack on KSTP anchor Matt Belanger

The journalist suffered a serious wound to his left eye.

UPDATE: Officials ID man who died as a result of bus confrontation

The 75-year-old told his attackers to "not be so loud" on the bus.