Skip to main content

Overstated Fargo flood predictions a head scratcher for National Weather Service

  • Author:
  • Updated:

Weather forecasters never offer guarantees, but the National Weather Service is taking a look at the reasons for an overstated spring flooding forecast for Fargo.

Forum Communications reports that NWS probability-based forecasts prompted volunteers to build 1.5 million new sandbags, none of which got wet in Fargo and only 100,000 of which were even placed.

“We’re kinda scratching our head,” said Steve Buan, a hydrologist with the weather service’s River Forecast Center in Chanhassen.

In mid-April, forecasters warned there was a 40 percent chance of the Red River topping 2009’s record 40.84-foot crest. Two weeks later, the flood fizzled into a non-event with a preliminary crest of 33.32 feet.

Why was the NWS forecast so far off? As March snow accumulated, Buan said, the weather service’s models didn’t know how soils would respond. The models predicted that between 60 and 75 percent of the snowpack would run off into streams, creating conditions similar to the 2006 flood. But the snow took an extra month to melt, and dry soils opened up like never before.

Models run by the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers showed “similar results,” said Alex Nelson, a hydrologic engineer for the corps.

Fargo Mayor Dennis Walaker said he believes the weather service is still living down the flood of 1997, when they incorrectly predicted levels in Grand Forks, and the city’s levees failed.

Next Up

Screen Shot 2022-05-20 at 6.49.01 AM

Deadly night in St. Paul sees 3 people killed, 1 arrest so far

The three incidents bring St. Paul's homicide total up to 18 this year.

police lights

2 killed in broad daylight drive-by shooting in Robbinsdale

The identities of the victims have not been released.

Seatbelted driver.

Road deaths involving unbelted people rose again in 2021

This is the second year in a row that the number has gone up.

hennepin sheriff hutchinson screengrab facebook

Hennepin Co. Sheriff Dave Hutchinson on paid leave for health reasons

The sheriff, who was recently convicted of drunk-driving, is set to stand down later this year.

Crane Lake

Flooding expected to worsen in MN's Arrowhead region

Hundreds of private homes are at-risk in northern St. Louis County.

St. Paul Police crash

St. Paul police: Kids in stolen car rammed squad, hid in porta-potty

The incident sent the Minnesota Capitol into a brief lockdown.


Watch: Storm updates after heavy hail slams Twin Cities

Sven Sundgaard is providing an update after Thursday's flash hail storm.

kim crockett facebook sos

MN GOP apologizes over antisemitic sequence in candidate's campaign video

Party leader says candidate didn't know the imagery perpetuated an antisemitic trope.

storm, severe

Tornado, severe thunderstorm watches issued in Minnesota

In addition to possible tornadoes, there is a threat for damaging winds and very large hail.

House sale keys door

High prices, stiff competition putting off homebuyers in Twin Cities

Prices continue to rise in the metro, but there are signs of buyer fatigue.

Screen Shot 2022-05-19 at 1.59.51 PM

Series of explosions at manufacturing plant injures 6 in Wisconsin

The blast rocked the Wisconsin town just before 7:45 a.m.

police lights squad car dark - Unsplash

Medford man dies in Le Sueur County crash

The 49-year-old was not wearing a seatbelt at the time of the crash.


National Weather Service: No tornado activity in southeastern Minn. storms

National Weather Service officials conclude Saturday that straight line winds and heavy rain -- not tornado activity as some people suspected -- caused the damage in Thursday's storms in Goodhue County.

Weather Service warns of fire and frost

The National Weather Service says very dry and windy weather will create elevated to critical fire weather conditions across parts of Minnesota. The southern two-thirds of the state is under the most serious wildfire warning. Separately, frost is possible across much of the state Monday night.

Technology upgrade at Weather Service should mean more specific warnings

New radar technology going in at the National Weather Service's Minnesota offices will help forecasters determine when tornadoes have touched the ground. It will also help them know how hard it's raining, which will improve flood forecasts.