Pay $299 or you get a bad review: Warning over scam targeting MN firms


A Twin Cities photography firm has been targeted by scammers who demanded they pay up $299 or they would post 25 negative reviews of their company online.

The Better Business Bureau has issued a warning to companies in the metro to be on the lookout for emails from someone threatening to post a series of fake, negative customer reviews online, before someone else gets in touch offering "reputation management services."

The Pioneer Press reports that Brad and Renee Nyberg, of Robbinsdale-based Nyberg Photography, were sent an email by someone identifying themselves as "James Frank" telling them that 25 bad reviews of their business would go on several websites unless they coughed up $299.

Then someone else emailed them under the name of "Elena Kagan" offering reputation management services. They ignored both, and negative reviews did start to appear online. Now they're worried it could drive away business.

"Today this scam targets photographers, but who will it target tomorrow? That’s the question we’re asking," said Dana Badgerow, president and CEO of BBB of Minnesota and North Dakota in a news release. "We’re advising all businesses that the best approach to dealing with scams like this is to not play along."

The PetaPixel website describes the four-step process these scammers go through, and have examples of some of the emails they send.

Photographers are a popular target for the scam artists, not least because they rely heavily on reputation and good reviews to generate business.

In the Nyberg case, the names Gina Ellis and Jennifer McMahon are also suspected of being used, though these names may not be real and others might be, the BBB notes.

If a business is targeted by the scam, they are advised to "not be bullied" and to fight back on the sites that the negative reviews have been posted, posting replies highlighting why the comment is a scam and putting a link in for people to follow.

It also said that anyone who does want a reputation management firm should do their research at the BBB website, seek references, and do comparison shopping to get an idea of costs.

Next Up

hazelewood burgers

3 Minnesota restaurants make it on 50 best burgers in America list

A travel website praised the restaurants' burgers in a recently released list.

Fire, firefighters

Firefighter critical after gun discharges during blaze, hitting him

The 35-year-old Cornell firefighter is hospitalized in critical condition

evelyn adams

After 2 years, sheriff's office seeks new leads in unsolved deadly home invasion

"The sheriff’s office is close to knowing exactly what occurred that night but needs your help," the sheriff's office said.

joseph heroff

Man charged in chase that ended with police fatally shooting suspect

The suspect who was shot has also been identified.

Royce Lewis

Twins' Royce Lewis tears his ACL, will undergo surgery

A huge blow for the former No. 1 draft pick.

Screen Shot 2021-01-22 at 9.08.16 PM

Police release cause of death for daughter of MN Supreme Court Justice and Allina CEO

Olivia Chutich died from a combination of excessive drinking and hypothermia.


Science Museum of Minnesota to reopen this weekend

The museum will be open on weekends with limited capacity and other safety precautions.

Keith Ellison

State officials push for shortened sentences for some elderly inmates

A bill introduced in the state Legislature would allow elderly inmates to apply for shortened sentences if they show evidence of rehabilitation.


Walz says state will soon announce next COVID vaccine priority groups

In a "short time," the governor expects to be able to give all Minnesotans an approximate date for when they'll be able to get the vaccine.