Skip to main content

Police believe domestic violence in Shoreview left 2 dead, 2 wounded

  • Author:
  • Updated:

More details are emerging about a shooting at a Shoreview home on Tuesday morning that left two dead and two injured.

Investigators say that they believe Johnny Simpson, 65, killed Minneapolis lawyer Nancy Sullivan, 57, and then killed himself. They believe the two had been in a relationship. The two lived at the home in the 5900 block of Grotto Street.

Nancy Sullivan

Ramsey County Sheriff’s Office investigators have not detailed exactly what happened at the house that led to the shootings Tuesday, but they did confirm that Sullivan had been in the process of moving out, and Simpson is the only suspected shooter. Officials reportedly recovered a handgun.

Two others were wounded: Katie Fay, 29, who was listed in critical condition, and Tony Brown, 28, believed to be Fay's boyfriend. Fay is Sullivan's daughter, the Star Tribune reports.

The Star Tribune notes that Sullivan's death could be the seventh metro-area killing of a woman by a boyfriend or husband this year. The Star Tribune dug out court records from Simpson’s 2002 divorce, in which his ex-wife accuses him of domestic abuse and bullying behavior.

An associate with the Minnesota Coalition for Battered Women tells the Pioneer Press that before Tuesday's shooting there had already been at least 14 domestic violence homicides in the state this year. That compares to 18 in all of last year.

An official with the Domestic Abuse Project tells FOX that women are at the greatest risk of domestic violence when they are leaving their partner. Carol Arhtur suggests women seek help from an advocacy group or police if they plan to leave a partner who has threatened them or has ready access to a weapon.

Nancy Sullivan was a partner with the law firm Barnes & Thornburg, which issued a statement expressing its sadness over her death.

Her company bio notes that Sullivan was active in community organizations, including Pathways to Success, Minnesota; Hope Family Community Services; and the Cristo Rey High School Mentorship Program. She was the pro bono legal services coordinator for the Minneapolis Barnes & Thornburg office.

"We are greatly saddened to learn about the loss of our beloved law partner and colleague, Nancy Sullivan," firm managing partner Peter Ekberg said in a statement. "Our thoughts and prayers go out to Nancy's family at this difficult time. She was an exceptional lawyer and a wonderful person. We will miss her greatly."

Next Up

Kellace McDaniel

Kellace McDaniel named Brooklyn Center police chief

McDaniel will officially begin his new job on Monday, June 27.

Thompson Lake, West St Paul

Twin Cities lake reopens following toilet waste spill

About 70,000 gallons of sewage spilled into the lake in mid-May.

Lake Sturgeon

MN lake sturgeon spawning event marks first of its kind in over a century

Conservationists celebrate a huge milestone for the living fossil of the fish world.

Parking lot of Plymouth Target

Police: 18-year-old woman carjacked outside Plymouth Target

The armed carjacking occurred just before 10 p.m. in the parking lot Wednesday.


St. Paul man pleads guilty to robbing Penn Lake Roast Beef, shooting owner

Devon Dwyane Reginald Glover, 22, shot Kevan Tran during the June 2020 robbery.

James Robert Hess.

Charges: Man shot brother in the eye, let his body decompose in camper

James Robert Hess faces second-degree murder charges for the shooting death of his brother, William Harold Hess Jr.

Christopher Payne and Kaley Wethern

Coupled charged after $75k worth of fentanyl pills seized during traffic stop

Christopher James Payne and Kaley Maria Wethern have been charged in the seizure.

Screen Shot 2022-05-25 at 9.34.43 AM

Video: Plane with blown tire makes emergency landing at MSP Airport

An aviation enthusiast caught the moment on video.

Pixabay - laptop computer dark screen

St. Paul man charged in online 'sextortion' scheme targeting at least 500 girls

Yue Vang, 31, was charged in U.S. District Court Wednesday.

Great Dane Rescue and Sanctuary

Emaciated Great Danes rescued after being found living in minivan

Great Dane Rescue of Minnesota and Wisconsin posted that two of the dogs are in "rough condition" and "barely hanging on."

Screen Shot 2020-05-26 at 10.28.52 AM

2 years since George Floyd's killing, Biden signs exec order on policing

The signing comes on the second anniversary of Floyd's murder by police in south Minneapolis.