Skip to main content

Public defender in Fitch trial praised – but the job's challenges continue

  • Author:
  • Updated:

Lauri Traub had one of the more high-profile cases a public defender in Minnesota may get – defending the Twin Cities man accused of killing Mendota Heights police officer Scott Patrick, a murder suspect so widely reviled by the public his trial had to be moved.

The Pioneer Press detailed the small, yet forceful steps Traub took to ensure her client, Brian Fitch Sr., got a fair trial.

Traub is an accomplished lawyer.

Her work helped lead to the shut down and reorganization of the beleaguered St. Paul drug crime lab in 2012, Sun This Week reported.

In 2013, she was named Attorney of the Year by Minnesota Lawyer.

And this year she took on the high-profile Fitch case in such a professional manner, that the family of officer Patrick actually thanked her (and her co-counsel) afterward for providing such a "vigorous defense," the Pioneer Press reports.

But awards and bigger cases don't mean a bigger salary for a public defender such as Traub.

The Hamline University School of Law graduate spoke with the Star Tribune about her side job as a waitress, at the hotel and restaurant Jake's near the Mall of America. That included a busy stint, mid-trial, when pond hockey players swarmed in from out of town, a plus for her since they tip well, she told the paper.

Challenges facing public defenders

Traub was first hired by the Public Defense Board in 1997.

She earned about $67,000 there last year, according to state payroll data. (FindingData pegs the average salary on that defense board at about $53,000.)

The median salary for a private practice attorney in 2013? About $114,000, the U.S. News and World Report says.

Then there's that waitress job to help her finances. For a public defender, having side work isn't uncommon.

Corey Sherman, a public defender in Minneapolis, told the National Law Journal "almost everyone" in her office had a second job. Sherman tutored law students and bartended weddings on the side.

For her, it was a combination of low starting pay for a public defender, and having to pay off student loans.

In addition, Traub and her colleagues are taking on more and more cases.

In 2010, MinnPost outlined the public defender "calamity" in Minnesota. Funding cuts sliced away staff members at those attorneys' offices, leaving the ones still there to cope with twice the amount of case work recommended by the American Bar Association.

The numbers, according to MinnPost: 423 full-time public defenders in 2008. Down to about 370 the next year. And then whittled even further, down to 350 by 2010.

So why do it?

Traub, Sherman and many others have repeatedly said the same thing: to defend the Constitution.

Next Up

Mock aircraft cabin.

MSP Airport debuts mock aircraft to help ease flying anxiety

The pre-flight experiences cover the TSA screening procedure, exploring a terminal, boarding a plane and meeting a pilot, and preparing for takeoff.

Scripps National Spelling Bee

These Minnesota kids will be competing at National Spelling Bee

The upcoming event in Maryland will be the first fully in-person Scripps National Spelling Bee since 2019.

covid, kids

New data shows how omicron has impacted kids in Minnesota

The new data shows breakthrough data during the omicron period, which began Dec. 19, 2021.

Javen Juan Moreno

Albert Lea shooting suspect arrested after 3 weeks on the run

He is accused of shooting a man in the upper thigh on May 1.


Motorcyclist, 59, killed after losing control on right curve

The Harley Davidson rider was thrown from his bike.

state capitol Minnesota

Minnesota's 2022 legislative session: What's happening?

A list of items agreed upon and yet to reach any bipartisan agreement in the latest legislative session.

water drain

Water main break floods 40-45 homes in St. Louis Park

The city says the rupture happened on Minnetonka Boulevard.

Eli Hart

Charges: 6-year-old Eli Hart shot up to 9 times by his mother

The 28-year-old is facing 2nd-degree murder charges.

dave lee wcco radio

Former WCCO Radio host Dave Lee moves into podcasts

His new podcast, called 'My First Concert,' launched last week.

Tow Boat

Tow boat collides with Mississippi River lock and dam in Alma, WI

The crash remains under investigation by the United States Coast Guard.

unsplash school bus

Police: Man in minivan approached kids, claimed he was former principal

Investigators say children were approached by a man in a white minivan who falsely claimed he'd been a local school principal.


Minnesota's COVID-19 update for Monday, May 23

The latest from the state health department.