Regulators tell Xcel to study retiring 2 Sherco coal generators


The Minnesota Public Utilities Commission said Thursday that Xcel Energy must take a detailed look at the future of its largest coal-fired power plant and study how soon its two oldest units could be retired.

Xcel's Sherco plant, located near Becker, supplies enough electricity to power more than 2 million homes and businesses.

MPR News reports that the future of the Sherco plant has generated more than 10,000 public comments this year. The vast majority of those comments want the commission to put pressure on Xcel to replace Sherco's two oldest units with clean energy alternatives.

The commission said that by July Xcel should complete a study of retirement scenarios that would start in 2020.

Environmental groups, led by the Sierra Club, wanted the PUC to adopt stronger language that would have required Xcel assume a 2020 retirement date for Sherco. They held community events around the state in November in an effort to increase the pressure on Xcel and state officials.

Polar explorer Will Steger was one several who testified before the PUC Thursday.

“Minnesotans sent a record 11,400 public comments to the PUC calling for a time line to replace these dirty plants,” said Steger, according to a report in the Star Tribune.

There were some who spoke in favor of keeping the plant, including Rep. Jim Newberger, R-Becker. Supporters cited the 350 jobs the plant provides to the area.

"It's economic devastation," Newberger said, according to the Star Tribune, when speaking of shuttering the units.

Commissioner Dennis O'Brien said the company should look at repowering the units with natural gas. It emits about half the amount of carbon dioxide as coal.

Xcel officials did not object to the study.

Previous studies have determined that continuing to burn coal at Sherco is the most cost-effective option. Company officials did acknowledge that an earlier study on the plant found that retirement of the plant at some point could make the most financial sense, depending on the future cost of carbon dioxide emissions.

Next Up

Co. Rd. 2 crash, Wakefield Twp.

Teen driver leaves road, crashes into three trees

Fortunately, the 16-year-old was not injured.

animal crossing mndot

Minnesota is getting its first highway crossing for animals

This will provide a safe way for animals to cross the street, and hopefully limit deer-vehicle collisions.

Screen Shot 2020-12-04 at 11.00.30 AM

Money Gal Coaching: Habits of a millionaire, just in time for the holidays?

Kelly Blodgett started Money Gal Coaching after paying down nearly $50K in debt in 18 months.

Mayo Belle Plaine

Mayo temporarily closes 5 clinics in southern MN amid COVID surge

The Mayo is reallocating staff to other sites as it deals with the COVID outbreak.

soda pop

MDH finds 'troubling' trend in how many sugary drinks students are consuming

Nearly half of students have a sugary drink a day. Health officials recommend limiting it to one per week or fewer.

Rent, mortgage, house, key, door

Minnesotans have till Dec. 7 to apply for housing assistance

Gov. Tim Walz and Lt. Gov. Penny Flanagan issued a press release urging Minnesotans behind on bills to apply


Dec. 4 COVID-19 update: 61 deaths, hospitalizations drop day-over-day

The update includes new data on cases, deaths, positivity rates and hospitalizations.

Kevin Nokels

Mystery over Duluth hospital CEO's sudden departure

Kevin Nokels stepped down this week, after less than 18 months in the role.

lola missing dog

1 dog still missing after woman's vehicle was stolen in Minneapolis

The woman was dropping her daughter off at daycare when someone stole her car with her two dogs inside.

Zachary Robinson

St. Paul man pleads guilty to murder of woman pregnant with his child

The 27-year-old will spend the next five decades in prison.

fire, firefighter

Fire at southern Minnesota farm kills 2,000 pigs

The fire started around 8 a.m. Thursday.

Minnesota Sex Offender Program Moose Lake

Man at Moose Lake sex offender facility dies from COVID-19

It's the first COVID-related death of anyone in Minnesota's sex offender program.


Activists prod regulators on Xcel's retiring coal plants

Clean-energy supporters are demanding that the Minnesota Public Utilities Commission order Xcel Energy to better plan how it will retire the two oldest and dirtiest coal-fired power plants at its Sherco Generating Station, which produces electricity for the Upper Midwest, the Pioneer Press reports. Renewable advocates packed an all-day hearing Thursday at the commission. They say Xcel has failed to study how wind- and solar-generated energy might replace the Sherco units.

State orders Xcel to study alternatives to coal-fired plants near Becker

The Public Utilities Commission ordered Xcel Energy to study the cost of new pollution control equipment at two of its coal-burning units in Sherburne County and compare that with the cost of replacing them with a cleaner alternative. Environmental groups consider the order a victory, but Xcel says it was planning something similar. The study is due next summer.