Ranked-choice voting: Yay or nay?


Minneapolis' ranked-choice voting system seemed to pass its first big test Tuesday. Final results were being calculated, with several races not officially decided, but fears that the complicated system would lead to weeks of vote-counting did not materialize.

Ranked-choice voting relies on voters to make first, second and third choices in a given race. A candidate needs 50 percent of the vote to win, and if no one gets that in the first round of counts, subsequent rounds eliminate bottom-tier candidates – and second and third choices are redistributed to remaining candidates. (An MPR video simplifies the concept below.)

But voters seemed to take the ranked-choice voting system in stride, and they were more annoyed with the long list of 35 mayoral candidates, which included Captain Jack Sparrow and Kurtis W. Hanna, of the Pirate Plank party. the Star Tribune reported. One Minneapolis election judge, Jane Martin, told the newspaper that a few voters redid their ballots after incorrectly filling out their ranked-choice votes, but most seemed to have done their research on how the system worked.

Ranked-choice seemed to have both fans and skeptics, but concern that widespread befuddlement would flummox voters proved to be unfounded.

There seemed to be relatively little confusion, the Pioneer Press reported. Judges were able to explain ranked-choice to voters who did not understand it, St. Paul election judge Julia New-Landrum told the Pioneer Press. "Just about 90 percent of people know what it is."

St. Paul also uses a ranked-choice system, although Mayor Chris Coleman easily won re-election in a clear landslide.

Late into Tuesday night, official winners could not be declared in the St. Paul Ward 1 city council race, the Minneapolis mayor race and in three of 13 city council wards in that city, the Pioneer Press noted.

KSTP talked to several voters about their experience with ranked-choice. "As to first, second and third, I don't want to vote for second and third. I know the candidate I want to vote for," Hugh Aylward told the station. Lisa Becker told KSTP that she had practiced her vote at home, but still didn't get it quite right on Election Day. "In 30 years of voting, this is the first time I made a mistake," she said.

Next Up

hazelewood burgers

3 Minnesota restaurants make it on 50 best burgers in America list

A travel website praised the restaurants' burgers in a recently released list.

Fire, firefighters

Firefighter critical after gun discharges during blaze, hitting him

The 35-year-old Cornell firefighter is hospitalized in critical condition

evelyn adams

After 2 years, sheriff's office seeks new leads in unsolved deadly home invasion

"The sheriff’s office is close to knowing exactly what occurred that night but needs your help," the sheriff's office said.

joseph heroff

Man charged in chase that ended with police fatally shooting suspect

The suspect who was shot has also been identified.

Royce Lewis

Twins' Royce Lewis tears his ACL, will undergo surgery

A huge blow for the former No. 1 draft pick.

Screen Shot 2021-01-22 at 9.08.16 PM

Police release cause of death for daughter of MN Supreme Court Justice and Allina CEO

Olivia Chutich died from a combination of excessive drinking and hypothermia.


Science Museum of Minnesota to reopen this weekend

The museum will be open on weekends with limited capacity and other safety precautions.

Keith Ellison

State officials push for shortened sentences for some elderly inmates

A bill introduced in the state Legislature would allow elderly inmates to apply for shortened sentences if they show evidence of rehabilitation.


Walz says state will soon announce next COVID vaccine priority groups

In a "short time," the governor expects to be able to give all Minnesotans an approximate date for when they'll be able to get the vaccine.


Video: How ranked-choice voting works

This will be used to elect some mayors.

Ranked-choice voting could mean weeks before winners are announced

Two St. Paul city council races are too close to call and will go to hand counts next week. One of those races has incumbent Dave Thune in a tight race for his seat in Ward 2.

Thune re-elected in St. Paul after ranked votes are re-tallied

Nearly a week after St. Paul voters cast their first ranked-choice ballots, Dave Thune was declared the winner of his city council race. Thune failed to gain a majority of the first-choice votes that were counted on Election Night. Counting two rounds of second-choice votes finally pushed him over 50 percent.