Updated:
Original:

Ranking the Vikings' 1st-round picks since the Herschel Walker trade

Randy Moss or Adrian Peterson at No. 1? Troy Williamson dead last? You tell us.
Author:

In 1988, the Vikings took future Hall of Fame guard Randall McDaniel with the 19th pick in the NFL Draft.

A year later the Herschel Walker trade happened, wiping out Minnesota's first-round picks for the next four years. Since then, the Vikings have taken 30 players in the first round. So we (and by "we" I mean "I, Joe Nelson") decided to rank them all, 1 through 30. Here's my list:

  1. Randy Moss, WR, 1998
  2. Adrian Peterson, RB, 2007
  3. Kevin Williams, DT, 2003
  4. Harrison Smith, S, 2012
  5. Daunte Culpepper, QB, 1999
  6. Chad Greenway, LB, 2006
  7. Bryant McKinnie, LT, 2002
  8. Korey Stringer, RT, 1995
  9. Robert Smith, RB, 1993
  10. Xavier Rhodes, CB, 2013
  11. Percy Harvin, WR, 2009
  12. Todd Steussie, LT, 1994
  13. Anthony Barr, LB, 2015
  14. Dewayne Washington, CB, 1994
  15. Teddy Bridgewater, QB, 2015
  16. Duane Clemens, DE, 1995
  17. Chris Hovan, DT, 2000
  18. Cordarrelle Patterson, WR/KR, 2013
  19. Trae Waynes, CB, 2015
  20. Dwayne Rudd, LB, 1997
  21. Michael Bennett, RB, 2001
  22. Matt Kalil, LT, 2012
  23. Sharrif Floyd, DT, 2013
  24. Laquon Treadwell, WR, 2016
  25. Kenechi Udeze, DE, 2004
  26. Christian Ponder, QB, 2011
  27. Derrick Alexander, DE, 1995
  28. Erasmus James, DE, 2005
  29. Dimitrius Underwood, DE, 1999
  30. Troy Williamson, WR, 2005

Explaining the rankings

Players are ranked by how much value they brought to the Vikings, regardless of how long they played. Basically, two years of solid quarterback play from Bridgewater was more valuable than the 19.5 sacks Clemons gave the Vikings in four years.

Moss ahead of Peterson? That's more like 1a and 1b. They're clearly the two best first-round picks since the Walker trade.

Had Stringer's career not been cut short by his death, he likely would've been as good if not better than McKinnie, who we ranked seventh overall because he started every game for the Vikings at left tackle from 2003-2010. Yes he was accused of hitting a bouncer with a pole (though he pleaded not guilty), and he was a key player on the Love Boat, but he was a pretty good left tackle on the field.

Guys like Rhodes, Barr, Waynes, Treadwell and Bridgewater still have plenty of time to track up the list (or down) as their careers advance.

Floyd actually looks like a worse pick now than he did when the Vikings took him 23rd overall in 2013. He was considered a top-five talent but slid because of injury concerns. Now his career appears to be in jeopardy because of injuries.

Udeze could've blossomed into something special but leukemia ended his career. He's currently the defensive line coach at USC.

Christian Ponder is not dead last on the list. He sucked, but it's not like he sucked as much as Alexander, James, Underwood and Williamson.

Next Up

mickey moore driver's license shared

Beleaguered Ward 9 city council candidate loses Strib endorsement

Mickey Moore has faced questions in recent days about where he actually lives.

CDC biohazard scientist health work

New clue may explain how rare tropical disease sickened Minnesotan

The disease, known as melioidosis, killed 2 people earlier this year.

Sen Mark Koran crop

MN lawmaker encourages donations for locals charged in Jan. 6 insurrection

"They are a good family!" Sen. Mark Koran wrote Friday.

money

Money Gal Coaching: Mastering the spiritual parts of money

Kelly Blodgett used her passion behind becoming debt free to launch Money Gal Coaching.

University of minnesota sign

U of M will now require proof that employees have been vaccinated for COVID

Previously, only students were required to be vaccinated.

Jim Hagedorn

Report reveals details about ethics investigation into Rep. Hagedorn

The congressman described the report's findings as "unfounded conclusions."

33462769592_d32f34fd48_k

SkyWest cancels hundreds of flights due to server error

More than 80 have been canceled at MSP Airport.

elk

First elk in more than 100 years spotted in parts of southern WI

The elk population was reintroduced to Wisconsin in recent decades.

grand marais

10 beautiful Minnesota cities to visit for outdoor adventures

These places are perfect for a day trip or a weekend getaway.

Related

Ranking the Vikings' 1st-round picks since the Herschel Walker trade

Randy Moss or Adrian Peterson at No. 1? Troy Williamson dead last? You tell us.

Look at the players the Vikings could've had with their 1st-round pick

Had the Vikings kept their first-round pick, these are some of the names that might have been available to them.

Look at the players the Vikings could've had with their 1st-round pick

Had the Vikings kept their first-round pick, these are some of the names that might have been available to them.

Will the Vikings trade back into the 1st round? Here's what it would probably take

It'll be difficult for the Vikings to trade into the first round of the NFL Draft.

Will the Vikings trade back into the 1st round? Here's what it would probably take

It'll be difficult for the Vikings to trade into the first round of the NFL Draft.

1st-round pick Vikes sent to Philly for Bradford could be a top 10 pick

The Eagles are probably getting a top 15 pick from the Vikings thanks to the Sam Bradford trade.

1st-round pick Vikes sent to Philly for Bradford could be a top 10 pick

The Eagles are probably getting a top 15 pick from the Vikings thanks to the Sam Bradford trade.

Vikings place 2018 1st-round pick Mike Hughes on PUP list

He can be activated at any time, but there's speculation that it won't be soon.