Religious freedom group argues MN city's nativity scene needs to go


One Minnesota city's Joseph, Mary and Jesus figurines won't be back in a government-run park.

The Wadena City Council voted Tuesday to take down a nativity scene that's traditionally been displayed at the city-owned Burlington Northern Park, KARE 11 reports.

So what's the deal?

This really all started back in January, when the Freedom from Religion Foundation sent a letter to the city, arguing that it's unlawful for a city to put up and maintain a religious scene, "thus singling out, showing preference for, and endorsing one religion."

You can read the full letter here.

The nativity scene

A nativity scene (also called a crèche) is a model or presentation that shows the birth of Jesus Christ according to Christian theology, and usually includes Joseph and Mary as well as animals, Merriam-Webster explains. It's generally put up before Christmas, then after Dec. 25 the baby Jesus figure is added, signifying his entrance into the world.

Having that being part of the local government violates the "Establishment Clause" of the First Amendment, the Freedom from Religion Foundation argues – the clause "prohibits" a government from establishing a religion, the U.S. Court website says.

The Wadena set-up includes an angel and the words "Gloria in excelsis Deo" – Latin for "Glory to God in the highest."

The Wisconsin-based foundation's letter says a "concerned citizen" contacted them, adding, "There are ample private and church grounds where religious displays may be freely placed."

The Wadena Pioneer Journal wrote back then that the foundation has pursued lawsuits in cases like this one.

The letter and complaint prompted the Wadena City Council to add a discussion over the nativity scene to its Tuesday meeting, the Brainerd Dispatch reported. The city's mayor, George Deiss, had previously told the paper it was "heartwarming" to get phone calls and letters from citizens, or have conversations on the street about how locals supported keeping the scene in place. It's been a longstanding tradition for the city.

One resident though, Tyler Rud, told WDAY he wants it taken down or moved not because he's against the religion – he just believes it's not the government's place to be involved.

Christianity in the US

Last year, amid similar stories across the country, Pew Research Center did a survey and found:

  • 44 percent of Americans said Christian symbols (such as a nativity scene) should be allowed on government property
  • 28 percent of U.S. adults said those symbols should only be permitted if they are accompanied by symbols from other religions, such as Hanukkah candles.
  • And 20 percent said there should be no religious displays on government property, period.

Earlier this year, Pew found about 70 percent of Americans identify as Christians – the highest number of Christians in any country in the world.

Next Up

Sergio Romo

Twins decline 2021 option on Sergio Romo

The Twins begin a potential overhaul in the bullpen.

high school football

'Scalpel approach' gives MN schools chance to keep playing sports

County infection rates are no longer the only thing that matters.


With the help of HVAC, Circus Juventas will host its first holiday shows

After months of canceled classes and shows, Circus Juventas is hosting its first ever holiday show, with safety precautions.

Cameron Dantzler

Vikings send Cameron Dantzler to COVID-19/reserve list

Dantzler's placement leaves the Vikings paper-thin at cornerback heading into Green Bay.

peterson fischbach

Elections 2020 preview: 7th Congressional District

Will Collin Peterson hang on for yet another term?

Zimmer and Hunter

Zimmer explains why he called Hunter's neck injury a 'tweak'

The coach also said Dalvin Cook should return from injury this week.


60 charged in magazine scam that netted $300M

It's being called the largest elder fraud scheme in the country.

Screen Shot 2020-10-28 at 10.30.23 AM

The Star Tribune is shutting down City Pages

The free newspaper was bought by the Star Tribune in 2015.

billy's on grand

Coronavirus: Billy's on Grand will close for winter

The restaurant is among a growing list of eateries to close for the winter months.


Catholic Bishops, other religious groups denounce Bachmann remarks

More than 40 organizations, including many religious groups, sent a letter to Rep. Michele Bachmann criticizing her claims that a Muslim group is infiltrating the federal government. The groups say Bachmann has accused people based on nothing more than their religious affiliation. They say that has serious implications for religious freedom.

MN native exports ideas for healthier cities to California

Fresh off a successful pilot project in Albert Lea, Dan Buettner is now working with three southern California cities on encouraging healthier lifestyles. In Albert Lea the three-year project produced an average weight loss of three pounds per resident and a 40 percent reduction in city health care expenses.