Skip to main content

Rochester aims to ban aggressive panhandling; preps for lawsuits

  • Author:
  • Updated:
    Original:

The city of Rochester is considering regulations to help curb aggressive panhandling after getting several complaints from residents who say they were intimidated by people asking for money on the sidewalk.

"These folks have a First Amendment right under our Constitution to ask for money, they don't have a First Amendment right to intimidate you or cause you to fear for concern out of your safety,” Rochester City Attorney Terry Adkins told ABC 6.

The City Council held a committee meeting Monday about possible regulations. Rochester is considering "Prohibitions against touching, verbal accosting, verbal aggression, as well as what I call the captive audience scenario," Adkins said, according to ABC 6.

The captive audience scenario would make it illegal for panhandlers to loiter within 15 feet of places like ATMs, outdoor cafes, public restrooms and public transportation, the Rochester Post Bulletin says. The city is also considering prohibiting panhandlers from standing on traffic medians and islands.

Supporters of the proposed ordinance say it's not aimed at panhandlers exactly, but is more about public safety.

City officials are considering how new regulations might be enforced. Rochester Police Chief Roger Peterson told ABC 6 that his department needs a clear definition on what consists of aggressive, intimidating panhandling because everyone's interpretation of it is different.

The council will have a public hearing before voting on the proposed ordinance during a July 21 meeting.

Potential lawsuits

City council members who support regulations to ban aggressive panhandling are basing the ordinance on those passed in Worcester, Massachusetts, in 2013 because that measure has been through legal challenges – and won.

Worcester, a city 45 miles west of Boston, has two ordinances very similar to those proposed in Rochester – one bans aggressive panhandling and creates a 20-foot buffer zone around ATMs, public transportation, etc. The other prohibits anyone from occupying traffic islands and medians for any purpose besides crossing the street, Worcester Magazine says.

The city went with a content-neutral approach to curb panhandling, which is one reason the ordinances have held up in court. Instead of just banning those asking for money, it limits all activities from politicians campaigning to kids selling cookies, the Rochester Post Bulletin notes.

The American Civil Liberties Union has filed a lawsuit against the city of Worcester, calling the panhandling law unconstitutional because it goes against First Amendment rights, but courts have upheld the ordinance so far. An appeals court decided in June to deny a preliminary injunction while the lawsuit is being pursued, so the city can continue to enforce the ordinance, according to MassLive.

A little over a week later, the Supreme Court ruled that buffer zones around reproductive health clinics are unconstitutional, which could affect Worcester's panhandling ordinance that creates buffer zones in some public spaces, Worcester Magazine notes.

Sarah Wunsch, a staff attorney at ACLU Massachusetts, is working on the case against Worcester's ordinances and says the panhandling buffer zone is more of an interference of freedom of speech than the reproductive clinic law, the magazine says.

Wunsch also says that any city that is considering similar panhandling ordinances "is really going to have to consider them much harder," the Rochester Post Bulletin reports.

However, the city of Rochester says it is prepared for pending lawsuits if it passes the panhandling ordinance.

"I would not be surprised if we were challenged," Adkins told the Rochester Post Bulletin. "But I like our chances in court."

Next Up

Screen Shot 2023-01-24 at 10.58.10 PM

Developing: Major police response to reported armed suspect in White Bear Lake

Authorities are asking people to avoid the area around the 3100 block of Karth Rd.

BNSF train

Man who died after being struck by train is identified

The incident remains under investigation.

JoshuaBuhlWashingtonCo

Charges: Oakdale man set house on fire, killing 5 cats

Joshua Buhl reportedly set the fire to "get law enforcement's attention," a complaint states.

UptownTargetGoogle

Arrest made after fire inside Uptown Target

Police were called to the store on a report of someone breaking in.

Ariyah Lewis

Missing 10-year-old girl last seen Jan. 20 in St. Paul

Ariyah Lewis was last seen on January 20 near the 1200 block of 7th Street in St. Paul.

West St Paul location

Erbert & Gerbert's opens new Minnesota location, with 7 more to follow

The sandwich chain has opened its doors in West St. Paul.

Screen Shot 2023-01-24 at 12.58.58 PM

Gov. Tim Walz budget plan calls for direct payments; tax cuts for seniors

Today's announcement completes a phased rollout of the budget proposal.

fsbc2022_chillstate_pineappleexpress_1610 (1)

Minnesota's first-of-its-kind THC drink distribution center opens

The distribution center is run by Fair State Brewing.

Screen Shot 2023-01-24 at 11.01.07 AM

South Minneapolis' Eat Street Crossing announces final restaurant concept

The upcoming food hall is taking over a historic building in the Whittier neighborhood.

JustusRamseyHouse

Court order halts demolition of historic St. Paul building

The Justus Ramsey House is listed on multiple historic registries.

Related