Skip to main content

SCOTUS reverses course, won't review #StandWithGavin transgender case

Gavin Grimm's efforts have inspired the #StandWithGavin hashtag.

The U.S. Supreme Court last year said it would take up the case of Gavin Grimm, a transgender male student at a Virginia high school that began using the boy's bathroom while transitioning in his sophomore year.

But on Monday, the Supreme Court reversed course – the Justices will not go over the case, and instead sent it back to a lower court for a review "in light of the guidance document issued" by federal departments under the Donald Trump administration.

Grimm will graduate from Gloucester High School this year. As a sophomore, Grimm's mother notified the school her son – whose was born female – identified as male, part of a transition process as he was treated for severe gender dysphoria, the ACLU explains. Grimm got permission from school administrators to use the boy's bathroom, and did so for two months until complaints came in.

In December of 2014, the school board voted on a new bathroom policy that required students to use the bathroom the corresponds with their biological sex, or a single-stall private restroom, as Fox News reported. Here's Grimm's testimony from before the decision.

The ACLU and ACLU of Virginia have been fighting that policy in court since then, arguing Title IX protections. The most recent ruling came from the Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals, which came down in favor of Grimm. That decision was appealed to a higher court – the U.S. Supreme Court – which was supposed to take up the case on March 28.

What happened Monday, and why

But in the court's order Monday (it's the top case listed here, "Gloucester County School Board v. G.G."), it says the judgment from the Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals is vacated (nullified, basically) and that the case will go back to the Fourth Circuit to be reconsidered.

The reasoning? New federal government guidelines.

The Washington Post breaks it down. Under President Barack Obama, the government said schools should let students use the bathroom that corresponds with their gender identity – and the Fourth Circuit used that philosophy to make its decision in favor of Grimm.

But last month, under new President Donald Trump, the federal government undid the Obama era policy, saying it was too vague and that the issue needs to be looked at more.

That prompted the U.S. Supreme Court to make its decision Monday, with the Fourth Circuit now having to review the case again while keeping the new federal guidelines (or lack thereof) in mind.

Grimm's case was seen as a pivotal moment for trans rights in the U.S., with the New York Times calling it the U.S. Supreme Court's "first encounter with transgender rights, and there was a good chance the case would have been one of a fairly sleepy term’s biggest decisions."

Grimm himself has become a high-profile figure for trans rights, with his case inspiring the #StandWithGavin hashtag.

The ACLU in a statement called the decision a "detour, not the end of the road." The school board, in a statement published by Bloomberg, said it's looking forward to "explaining why its commonsense restroom and locker room" doesn't violate the Constitution.

Next Up


80 mph winds, large hail possible with severe storms in MN

A severe thunderstorm watch is in effect for much of the state until 3 a.m. Saturday.


30 people evacuated as flooding hammers small town

It's assumed that at least eight inches of rain fell in Randall, with more heavy rain expected Friday night into Saturday morning.

Intersection in Rochester.

Boy dies in motorcycle crash in Rochester

Police are investigating as of Friday afternoon.

Tab2FileL (13)

Numerous severe storms likely in Minnesota Friday night

Watch the video for the full details with meteorologist Sven Sundgaard.

court room

Teen pleads guilty in shooting death of 15-year-old girl in Columbia Heights

Damico Jamal-Tokyo High will receive a sentence in juvenile court, along with an adult prison sentence.

Screen Shot 2022-04-25 at 11.00.01 AM

Walz wants to use surplus money to send direct payments to Minnesotans

It's a renewed effort from a previous proposal from Walz and Lt. Gov. Peggy Flanagan's supplemental budget in January.

Ron Johnson

Jan. 6 committee says aide for WI senator tried to give fake elector info to Pence

The attempt was discovered through text messages in the ongoing public hearing held by the Jan. 6 select committee.

Stock U of M sign

Minnesota state colleges boosting tuition again by 3.5%

The Minnesota State system's Board of Trustee's approved the increase Wednesday.


Minnesota's COVID-19 update for Friday, June 24

The next daily update will be provided Monday, June 27.

Pro choice rally

Walz, Jensen react to historic Supreme Court reversal of Roe v. Wade

After voting to overturn Roe, conservative Justice Clarence Thomas has hinted contraception and same-sex marriage protections should follow.

16362 County Rd 81, Maple Grove, Minnesota - October 2021 (4)

2-year-old killed in crash on County Road 81 in Maple Grove

The crash occurred Thursday evening on County Road 81.

police tape

BCA issues new details about St. Michael standoff, shooting

New details say a St. Cloud police officer struck the suspect with gunfire.


Police probably won't be allowed on St. Paul's police review board anymore

The group that handles complaints against police officers would no longer have police officers on it.

'Sanctuary' communities won't get DOJ money, so will MN be affected?

None of Minnesota's communities consider themselves "sanctuary" – though a few step closer to it than others.

Trump's own tweets listed as one reason the transgender military ban was blocked

Here's why the judge included the president's Twitter behavior as part of her ruling.

Charges: 2 people helped ER doctor arrange female genital mutilation procedures

The charges say two Minnesota girls were brought to Michigan to have it done.

The mother of an Illinois man killed by St. Paul police is suing

Authorities have said Cordale Handy had a gun, but the lawsuit argues he wasn't a threat.

WTH is NSEERS and why are people talking about it?

NSEERS was used post-9/11 to track male visitors from certain countries – mainly in the Middle East.

What Minnesota's U.S. lawmakers have said about Trump's immigration order

What Minnesota' U.S. lawmakers have said about Donald Trump's executive order restricting travel and refugees.

Planned Parenthood brings 87K petitions to Paul Ryan

The group could lose hundreds of millions of dollars in federal funding if a proposal from House Republican leaders gets approved.