Skip to main content

After the upset: 'Shock' in New Orleans when Minneapolis awarded Super Bowl

  • Author:
  • Updated:

The matchup was viewed as lopsided. In bids to host the 2018 Super Bowl, New Orleans had been the favorite over Minneapolis (with Indianapolis a more distant third).

The Big Easy was a sentimental favorite. New Orleans will celebrate its 300-year anniversary in 2018. NFL owners, who decide Super Bowl venues, had a soft spot for 87-year-old Saints owner Tom Benson, who was perhaps making his last bid.

And there was this: New Orleans has hosted 10 Super Bowls, and had never lost a bid.

So New Orleans officials were stunned when NFL owners voted Tuesday afternoon to give the marquee February event to wintry Minneapolis, where the new $1 billion Vikings stadium has not yet been built. Star Tribune columnist Jim Souhan put it this way: "Congratulations to the Wilfs. If you ever feel tempted to question their business acumen, remember this. They just sold frostbite to billionaires."

The news left New Orleans officials shocked, the New Orleans Times Picayune reported. The newspaper collected various reactions:

"This was more of a vote for Minneapolis and a new stadium much more than it was a vote against New Orleans and our presentation." - Greater New Orleans Sports Foundation president and CEO Jay Cicero

"The stadiums, the new stadiums, are obviously a big factor and drive the influence of owners from their perspective." - NFL Commissioner Roger Goodell

"It's the first time we've been up directly against a new stadium development. In this case, we were in competition with a half a billion dollars of public investment and half a billion dollars of private. And that was a tough thing to overcome. In this case, the sheer value of our destination couldn't quite overcome the monetary part." - New Orleans presenter Steve Perry, the president of the New Orleans Convention and Visitors Bureau

"Having never lost a Super Bowl bid, this is uncharted territory for us. It's very disappointing, particularly given the popularity of New Orleans as a destination and a major sports event host city." - Lt. Governor Jay Dardenne

The comments section under the Times Picayune story make for interesting reading – and more pointed opinions. A sampling:

"Minneapolis? Really? Habitrail central in the winter time! Sure, the airport has more direct flights, but what are you going to do in MSP after that direct flight lands during winter? I've lived there. You either have cloudy days in the 20s or clear days in the teens."

"The Super Bowl is about the game, not a city. Using the 300th Anniversary of New Orleans as a bargaining chip, our self-aggrandizement, was our downfall!"

"No doubt the decision was based on how much tax money the citizens of Minneapolis had to dish out to support the 'non profit' NFL."

"This is what happens when you can't keep the lights on at the big game. Or on uptown streets. Or downtown streets. Or any streets, really."

"This had absolutely nothing to do with the qualifications. It had nothing to do with lights or power issues. This was not an intentional insult to New Orleans. It had everything to do with the NFL owners keeping pressure on local governments to keep the cash flowing in to build stadiums that can make the owners more money."

A theme emerged in other reactions: The decision was about money.

"Build a stadium and the Super Bowl will come. That’s the reality of today’s NFL, where one of the top priorities is getting a publicly funded, luxury-box-filled football palace in each city," Boston Globe sports reporter Ben Volin wrote.

More general reaction from the Twittersphere:

Next Up


Reward to find person who left kittens to die in freezing WI cold

The cats were thrown from a vehicle, according to a witness.

metro mobility bus

Charges: Man led police on multi-city pursuit in stolen Metro Mobility bus

The bus had been left unattended with the keys inside when it was stolen.

Bell Ramsey Co. Jan 22 - crop

Charges: Man fatally shot mother of his child during argument

Officers found her on the ground outside the couple's home.


Minnesota's COVID-19 update for Wednesday, January 26

More than 15,000 new cases in today's update.

Kwesi Adofo-Mensah

The biggest personnel decisions facing the new GM

Kwesi Adofo-Mensah has some tricky personnel decisions coming up in the near future

Kwesi Adofo-Mensah

What to know about new Vikings GM Kwesi Adofo-Mensah

The former Wall Street trader is an analytics guru who appreciates collaboration.

metro transit southwest light rail green line extension construction

Southwest LRT may cost $210M more, take 3 years longer to build

The Met Council is proposing a settlement with one of its contractors due to disputes over construction changes.

Rick Spielman

Spielman: 'That head coach has to have a relationship with that QB'

"I think the No. 1 thing you’re looking for is that head coach has to have a relationship with that quarterback."

Screen Shot 2022-01-26 at 6.36.25 AM

Gallery: France 44 to build two-story addition, rooftop patio

The Minneapolis liquor store and cheese shop is stepping up its events and class offerings.