Skip to main content

St. Paul man admits killing intruder, hiding the body in his garage for a month

The killer said he hoped maggots would eat the body.
  • Author:
  • Updated:

What's happened?

John Michael Erickson, of St. Paul, has agreed to a plea deal over the killing of 47-year-old Allan "Buddy" Bishara Aguilar in June of last year.

As part of the deal, Erickson, 50, has agreed to plea guilty to 1st degree manslaughter and felony interference with a dead body.

He's due to appear for sentencing in court at 1:30 p.m. on Apr. 9, the Ramsey County attorney told GoMN.

What did he do?

According to the criminal complaint, Aguilar was last seen alive on June 13, 2017, and prior to this Erickson had been heard threatening to shoot Aguilar if he ever saw him again.

Erickson later told police that the argument with Aguilar came after he allowed a neighbor to work on cars in his Lawson Avenue East garage, later finding out that some of his tools had been taken and the car was stolen. The neighbor blamed Aguilar for stealing the tools. 

Around the time Aguilar went missing, Erickson said he went into his garage after hearing a noise, and claims he was struck with a bat by an intruder.

He then proceeded to wrestle the man in the garage before grabbing a metal jack from his tool bench, hitting him four or five times on the head.

Aguilar suffered catastrophic injuries, with an autopsy finding "extensive fractures" on his skull including at the base.

Erickson claimed he didn't know the man was Aguilar till the next morning, saying he was "fighting for his life and his family."

His body was found a month later

Several neighbors noticed Erickson was acting erratically in the ensuing few weeks, with one coming across him drunk and crying on June 27 or 29, telling her "I did something really bad."

They also noticed he'd kept his garage closed. It was usually found open, and a place where friends and neighbors would gather and drink.

One witness went into the garage with Erickson on July 10 and noticed a "strange smell" that he recognized from his time working in a slaughterhouse.

Eventually, a group of Aguilar's friends went into the garage on July 14 and reported to police his body was in there.

His decomposing body was found wrapped in several sheets of plastic and hidden beneath some building debris. 

Speaking to police later, Erickson said he didn't know what to do after he killed Aguilar, and with a stolen car in garage, so he wrapped him in plastic and hid him, hoping "the maggots would take care of the body."

Erickson has three prior felony convictions: failure to register as a predatory offender, terroristic threats, and 3rd degree criminal sexual conduct.

Next Up

Plow 2 (1)

Photos reveal damage from gunshots to Minneapolis snowplow

A hydraulic line and three tires were damaged in the shooting.

unsplash - school classroom students

Minneapolis schools confirm return to in-person teaching Monday

The school district shifted to online learning almost two weeks ago as rising COVID cases led to staff and bus driver shortages.

Flickr - Superior National Forest Boundary Waters

Mineral leases for proposed Twin Metals mine near Boundary Waters canceled

A review by the DOI found "significant legal deficiencies" with the leases' 2019 renewal.


Reward to find person who left kittens to die in freezing WI cold

The cats were thrown from a vehicle, according to a witness.

metro mobility bus

Charges: Man led police on multi-city pursuit in stolen Metro Mobility bus

The bus had been left unattended with the keys inside when it was stolen.

Bell Ramsey Co. Jan 22 - crop

Charges: Man fatally shot mother of his child during argument

Officers found her on the ground outside the couple's home.


Minnesota's COVID-19 update for Wednesday, January 26

More than 15,000 new cases in today's update.

Kwesi Adofo-Mensah

The biggest personnel decisions facing the new GM

Kwesi Adofo-Mensah has some tricky personnel decisions coming up in the near future

Kwesi Adofo-Mensah

What to know about new Vikings GM Kwesi Adofo-Mensah

The former Wall Street trader is an analytics guru who appreciates collaboration.

metro transit southwest light rail green line extension construction

Southwest LRT may cost $210M more, take 3 years longer to build

The Met Council is proposing a settlement with one of its contractors due to disputes over construction changes.


austin herbst -

Man pleads guilty, admits he killed father in 2013 and dumped his body in WI

Austin Herbst and his mother were both charged in connection to Gary Herbst's death seven years after he was killed.

Update: Man arrested in connection with deadly stabbing near light rail station

The victim and killer were "known to each other," police have said.

Mother and son charged in hit-and-run that killed St. Paul restaurant worker

The victim was popular restaurant worker Jose Hernandez Solano.

Man being held on suspicion of killing his mom in North St. Paul

The 46-year-old was found dead with stab wounds.

David Ekers

Charges: Man killed his grandmother with wrench, tried to kill mom and sister

The suspect said he didn't want to go back on mental health medication or return to a hospital.

Fleeing scene after machete threat, man causes fatal crash in St. Paul

The 26-year-old man crashed into a vehicle and a garage.

Man killed in domestic dispute, wife arrested for murder

The 53 year old died in hospital after suffering upper body injuries.