Standing Rock calls pipeline ruling a victory – but will DAPL be shut off?

A judge says a thorough oil spill analysis for the Dakota Access Pipeline wasn't done. So what happens next?

A federal judge says the possible impacts of an oil spill along the Dakota Access Pipeline weren't fully explored during planning stages – and now there's a chance it will stop operating so more environmental analysis can be done.

This comes from a (very long) U.S. District Court ruling on Wednesday. It's a response to the Standing Rock Sioux Tribe's latest legal challenge to the controversial pipeline. The tribe argues the Army Corps of Engineers didn't fully consider the environmental impacts of the pipeline before giving permits that allowed DAPL to be completed.

In the opinion, Judge James Boasberg sides (at least in part) with the tribe.

Boasberg writes that the Army Corps followed through on the National Environmental Policy Act "in many areas" when allowing the pipeline to be constructed beneath the federally managed Lake Oahe in North Dakota.

But they whiffed in one key area: A possible oil spill.

The Army Corps didn't "adequately consider" what could happen to fishing rights, hunting rights, or other aspects of the environment if there were to be an oil spill, the opinion says.

What happens next?

The Standing Rock Sioux Tribe chairman is calling this a "victory," and blaming the Trump administration for "hastily" ignoring environmental considerations.

"We applaud the courts for protecting our laws and regulations from undue political influence and will ask the Court to shut down pipeline operations immediately," Chairman Dave Archambault II said.

The Associated Press describes the court ruling as a "lifeline."

But nothing's changing, at least for now.

The Army Corps will need to redo those parts of the environmental analysis.

But whether the Dakota Access Pipeline will need to stop operations while that happens hasn't been decided yet. (It just started moving oil on June 1.) Judge Boasberg called that a "separate question," and said it'll be looked at in the future. The Washington Post says hearings for that will start June 21.

Background on the pipeline

The $3.8 billion pipeline carries oil from the Bakken shale fields in North Dakota, through South Dakota and Iowa, before eventually reaching distribution centers in Illinois.

Energy Transfer Partners has said the pipeline was built in one of the safest, most technologically advanced ways possible.

The company was given the go-ahead by the Trump administration to complete the pipeline earlier this year, reversing an earlier decision from the Obama administration.

Next Up

Governor Tim Walz

Walz will announce timeline 'to end all COVID-19 restrictions'

The details will be revealed in the governor's planned Thursday address.

Associate wearing PPE 2

Amazon to open new facility in St. Cloud this year, creating 'hundreds' of jobs

St. Cloud Mayor Dave Kleis shared the news in his State of the City address this week.

State Patrol

State Patrol: Semi driver kills self after being stopped by troopers

The incident happened Wednesday morning in the Miracle Mile shopping center parking lot in Rochester.

state fair beer

Money Gal: Don't forget the most important items in your budget

Kelly started Money Gal Coaching after paying down more than $46,000 in debt in just 20 months.


Crash kills motorcyclist near Treasure Island casino

The crash took place just before midnight.

The Lunds & Byerlys on Cedar Avenue in Minneapolis, three weeks prior to opening.

New Lunds & Byerlys opens in Minneapolis this month

It's been built in the spot formerly occupied by Bergan's SuperValu.

valleyfair food workers 1

Valleyfair food workers getting a pay raise for 2021 season

The starting wage will increase from $11.25 an hour to $15 an hour.

Screen Shot 2021-05-05 at 11.10.59 AM

Peloton recalls treadmills after child's death, dozens of other injuries

Officials say owners should stop using them immediately.

Screen Shot 2020-05-29 at 6.42.54 AM

St. Paul man gets prison, ordered to pay $12M for burning of 3rd Police Precinct

He was among four Minnesota men charged in connection to the fires at the Third Precinct following George Floyd's murder.


Some MN high schools are refusing to pay MSHSL's pandemic fee

The installment fees were approved as a "short-term" budget fix.

Grand Portage State Park

Senate GOP threatens State Parks, DNR shutdown if 'Clean Cars' rule isn't scrapped

Republicans are willing to hold up the omnibus environment bill to stop the MPCA from enacting Clean Cars rules.


Judge clears the way for oil to move through DAPL as soon as next week

The company building the Dakota Access Pipeline has indicated it wants to start moving oil through the new line soon.

Reports: Dakota Access Pipeline will get permission to build from the Army Corps

The Army Corps of Engineers filed court documents signaling it will allow the pipeline to be built.

A crude oil pipeline in ND spilled thousands of gallons into a waterway

The spill happened about 150 miles from the site of DAPL protests.

The protested North Dakota pipeline will be blocked for (at least) a bit longer

The possibility of letting the pipeline company drill underneath Lake Oahe has been under review.

Minnesota is not helping ND authorities with the Standing Rock protests anymore

The last of the Minnesota deputies left Monday morning, a North Dakota spokesperson said.

More protesters arrested at Standing Rock, as drilling equipment moves into place

The pipeline company said this week it's moving drilling equipment to Lake Oahe.

Standing Rock protesters have been ordered to leave immediately

"These persons are ordered to leave the evacuation area immediately, and are further ordered not to return to the evacuation area."

Violent clashes at Standing Rock protests being looked at by a grand jury

21-year-old Sophia Wilanksy suffered a gruesome arm injury while at the protests.