Skip to main content

Taxing 401(k) contributions would be disastrous for millennials

It's one of the possible tax reforms being (quietly) considered in D.C., according to a report.

A little snippet from this Politico story on White House plans for tax reform has come under the microscope: a proposal to tax contributions made to 401(k) retirement plans.

Politico described it as "one idea quietly being discussed" in the White House. It would see people saving into a 401(k) workplace pension plan taxed on the money they contribute now, rather than when they withdraw it in retirement.

This would be an utterly disastrous change to what is currently the best retirement vehicle for savers (as I've written about in this Tip Jar column), and millennials would be particularly hard hit.

The Washington Post and DailyKos are also decrying any attempt to tax 401(k) contributions.

I can't imagine such an unpopular measure ever being implemented, but stranger things have happened. Here's why it'd be such a terrible idea.

It could cost people tens, potentially hundreds of thousands of dollars

Right now, 401(k) contributions are tax-deferred, so the money is taken straight from your salary before tax is applied, with the idea you pay tax when you withdraw it in retirement.

There are two big ways taxing 401(k) contributions would hit you big-time in the pocket.

1. You would lose the currently tax-free element of the money you save into your 401(k). This would not only reduce the amount you're saving by however much tax you pay, but also reduce the compound interest you accrue as that money is invested. Over the course of 30-40 years of saving (i.e. for current young workers), the loss could easily be six figures.

2. Your income in retirement will almost certainly be lower than when you're earning a salary, so if you pay tax now, you miss out on paying less tax as a pensioner.

It's a disincentive to save

Young people aren't saving enough for retirement as it is. Bloomberg reports only 41 percent of workers at companies offering 401(k) plans are contributing to one regularly.

And those millennials who do save into one aren't saving enough, with only 16 percent taking advantage of the full "match" offered by their employer, according to Business Insider.

Taking away the ability to save pre-tax would be even more of a disincentive to save for young workers, many of whom already have tight household budgets to deal with.

Taxing contributions now, rather than withdrawals later, would make 401(k)s little better than post-tax Roth IRAs, which should (where possible) be used as a complement to a 401(k) rather than as the main retirement vehicle.

Kicking the can down the road

Finally, the idea is being considered because it would be used to fund corporate and individual tax cuts now according to Politico.

I'm not going to get into the debate on who benefits from such cuts and who doesn't. But what I will comment on is the fact that the government would effectively be front-loading its tax contributions, getting tax revenue now instead of in 30-40 years' time when 401(k) holders are ready to withdraw.

This screams "gigantic budget deficit" decades down the line, something for – you guessed it – the current and upcoming generations of young adults to worry about.

Who's to say we wouldn't get to that point and circumstances are so dire that we are faced with the unthinkable? "Sorry, we have no money, we're going to have to tax your 401(k) withdrawals as well."

Next Up

Flickr - face masks covid pole - Ivan Radic

'Everyone should really be masking up' in public, Malcolm says

The health commissioner said residents have gotten "a little bit lax" with some protective measures.

Byron Buxton

Byron Buxton believes he's the best player in baseball

"Nobody [does] the things that I do. I know that."

unsplash medical marijuana

Edibles coming to Minnesota's medical marijuana program

MDH also announced it will not add anxiety as qualifying condition.

plow, snowplow, snow

Plowable snow possible this weekend in Minnesota

Up to half a foot of snow could fall within the heaviest band.

Best Buy - jjbers, Flickr

Police reveal new details about 'coordinated' Best Buy thefts

A large group stole thousands of dollars in merchandise from three Twin Cities Best Buy stores.

Seven Points exterior - 2

New tenant revealed for former Libertine spot in Uptown

The space will combine playful art offerings with a restaurant.

white Christmas

What are Minnesota's chances of a white Christmas this year?

The Twin Cities averages a white Christmas about 3 out of every 4 years.

ilhan omar press conference voicemail screengrab 11.30.21

'You will not live much longer b***': Rep. Omar shares threatening voicemail

Omar's office received the call hours after Rep. Boebert posted her video about the MN congresswoman.

Screen Shot 2021-12-01 at 11.24.09 AM

ESPN's 'Booger' makes fun of Wild fans' record cup snake

He's the same guy who thought the "Minneapolis Miracle" was bad for the Vikings.

brian ingram

Woodfired Cantina closes at Keg and Case in St. Paul

Restaurateur Brian Ingram is focusing on growing his other concepts.

giant bear

Video: 'THE fattest bear we have ever seen' spotted on MN trail camera

"This might be THE fattest bear we have ever seen in our area," researchers said.


Who would be the winners and losers from the Senate tax bill?

The Senate passed the tax bill late Friday night.

The Tip Jar: How I'm using an app to save and invest money

It's helping me set aside a few extra bucks every week.

Employers could soon start helping you pay off your student debts

A new program allows companies to help employees with student loans.

I'm turning 30 ... what should my money priorities be?

Now is the time to assure your financial future.

Too many Americans are passing up on free money – a 401(k) plan

The 401(k) is considered the pinnacle of U.S. retirement plans, but the majority of Americans aren't saving into one.

6 ways to save money on your Christmas decorating

It's the time of year when everyone is decking their halls.