Updated:
Original:

TCF Bank tricked customers into expensive overdrafts, federal agency says

The Wayzata-based bank is accused of obscuring overdraft fees and failing to explain they were optional.
Author:

TCF Bank is in trouble with federal regulators, who are suing the Minnesota company for "tricking" customers into what it called "costly overdraft services."

The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau announced the suit on Thursday, accusing TCF of designing its application process in a way that obscured overdraft fees and made an overdraft seem mandatory in order to open a new account.

It also claims TCF adopted a "loose definition of consent" that effectively placed its existing customers into the overdraft service, and "pushed back on any customer who questioned the process."

Bureau Director Richard Cordray said TCF was "tricking consumers ... to preserve its bottom line," adding: "TCF bulldozed its way through protections against automatic overdraft enrollment and then celebrated its unusual sign-up success."

TCF Bank, which is based in Wayzata, issued a statement Thursday saying, "Although we remain hopeful that we can reach an appropriate resolution, TCF intends to vigorously defend against the CFPB’s complaint. We believe that at all times our overdraft protection program complied with the letter and spirit of all applicable laws and regulations, and that we treated our customers fairly."

In December, TCF Bank topped the CFPB's list of the most complained about banks in America.

Suit claims bank offered bonuses for sign-ups

The suit says that customers with TCF checking accounts would be charged $35 every time they overdrafted by spending/withdrawing more than was in their account.

In 2010, federal laws took effect that banned banks from charging overdraft fees on ATM and one-time debit card transactions unless consumers – new and existing – agreed to opt in to the program. (If a consumer didn't opt in, the transaction would be blocked if there wasn't enough money in the account.)

But TCF, expected to take a $182 million revenue hit as a result of the new rules, found "the less information it gave consumers about opting in, the more likely consumers would opt in," according to the financial bureau's suit.

TCF did this, the bureau argues, by:

  • placing the "opt in" decision immediately after a series of other mandatory decisions a customer had to agree to;
  • giving staff scripts that didn't explain that the opt in was optional;
  • and failing to spell out to existing customers that they faced a $35 overdraft charge by keeping their account the way it is.

The CFPB's complaint also alleges bonuses were offered to branch staff who got consumers to sign on, with branch managers being able to rake in up to $7,000 in bonuses for getting a high number of opt-ins during 2010.

Even when bonuses were phased out, regional managers would set targets for staff, who believed (wrongly) they would lose their jobs if they didn't achieve them.

TCF Bank, in its response, says the CFPBs claims are contradicted by the fact some of its customers opened accounts online with no face-to-face interaction, and still 60 percent signed up for the overdraft charges.

It also says there were "virtually no complaints" – 341 between 2010-2015 – from its customers relating to their decision to opt-in.

Next Up

FAPqmybVkAQ5h1p

Vikings come from behind for resounding win over Seattle

Kirk Cousins was lights out and Alexander Mattison didn't a miss a beat in place of Dalvin Cook.

Cheryl Reeve

One and done: Lynx season ends with playoff loss to Chicago

Minnesota was faced with a one-and-done situation despite owning the league's third-best record.

Dalvin Cook

Vikings: Dalvin Cook is OUT of Seahawks game

The star running back hasn't recovered from an ankle injury.

snapchat

Boy arrested after making threats towards school in Anoka

An image shared on Snapchat warned of the "best school shooting yet."

Ambulance hospital emergency

Four killed in crashes after deadly start to weekend on MN roads

The latest figures show there have been 349 road deaths in Minnesota this year.

Delta

In crackdown on unruly passengers, Delta urges other airlines to share no-fly lists

The airline says it's a bid to "further protect airline employees across the industry."

Screen Shot 2020-06-15 at 7.11.05 AM

St. Cloud State student-athlete suspended from team following alleged assault

The incident reportedly took place off campus on Sep. 18.

Gopher Football

U of M-barrassed: Gophers shocked by Bowling Green

The Falcons snapped a 21-game non-conference winning streak in front of a homecoming crowd.

Andrew Wiggins

Andrew Wiggins applies for exemption to COVID vaccine, is rejected

Wiggins could miss a large chunk of the season without the vaccine.

Related

Update: TCF Bank says its Monday issues should be fixed

The Plymouth-based bank was experiencing "processing delays" for certain deposits.

Free checking returns to TCF Bank

Wayzata-based TCF Financial Corp. says it is eliminating monthly account maintenance fees for all customers, regardless of minimum balance, direct deposit or transaction level requirements. The Business Journal notes TCF Bank began charging fees in early 2010 after new federal regulations were expected to reduce revenue from overdraft fees.

Minnesota's TCF Bank to merge with Detroit-based bank

The TCF name is staying, with Detroit's Chemical Bank changing its name.

A ranking of the most complained-about banks is not topped by Wells Fargo

Researchers say they were surprised to find a smaller, Minnesota-based bank topped their list

1024px-TCF_Bank_Corporate_Building_(34635667776)

TCF Bank to become Huntington as part of $22 billion merger

The bank, which will soon be known as Huntington, was founded in Minneapolis in 1923.

Widespread banking outage angers Wells Fargo customers

Mobile and online banking is affected, as are some ATMs and credit card services.