Skip to main content

The Tip Jar: At a restaurant, should I tip pre- or post-tax?

Have you ever thought about this when dining out?
  • Author:
  • Updated:
    Original:

Given there are dozens of service industries where tipping is expected in the U.S., it can be quite the minefield for consumers to navigate.

Most of us will commonly run into tipping situations when eating out. The Tip Jar looked at the etiquette for when and how much to tip for food and drink in this column.

But there remain some burning questions that need answering, so we've dived back into the world of tipping to provide some more guidance.

Do you tip pre- or post-tax?

This question came from a reader, Barb, who noticed that some restaurants have started putting different percentages at the bottom of itemized receipts – some which figure in the tip on the pre-tax amount and others the post-tax.

"I know it's not much difference but what is the correct tip, pre- or post-tax?" she asked. It's a good question and one I hadn't considered before.

I tend to tip post-tax just because it's the number at the bottom of the receipt. 

But is it right we do that? After all that's not part of the service the restaurant has provided – it's tax levied by the city/state on your food and drink.

(Here's a breakdown of Minnesota sales tax for dining/drinking, by the way).

What's the verdict?

Sometimes the decision is made for us, with this LA Times piece noting restaurants that feature "suggested gratuities" or tipping options that appear on credit card transactions are often based on the post-tax calculation.

But several tipping etiquette experts and websites suggest you shouldn't tip post-tax at restaurants.

The Emily Post Institute says wait service at sit-down and buffet eateries should be tipped based on the pre-tax total, though the institute seems to think it's OK to tip post-tax on your bar tab.

The Etiquette Scholar website agrees, saying at restaurants you should only tip on the pre-tax amount of the bill, not on the total.

Laura Barclay, an etiquette expert from the Civility Center, told Tip Jar she's also of the opinion that tipping should be calculated pre-tax.

The difference is negligible, coming to as little as $2 on a $100 bill. And if you're happy with your service and want to be generous to a server relying on tips for their livelihood, I'm sure most of us wouldn't begrudge them that.

But if you have a principled stance against post-tax tipping, now you know some etiquette experts have your back.

If you have any money questions you'd like Tip Jar to look into, send them to adam@gomn.com or @AdamUren.

Next Up

motorcycle

Motorcyclist, 59, killed after losing control on right curve

The Harley Davidson rider was thrown from his bike.

state capitol Minnesota

Minnesota's 2022 legislative session: What's happening?

A list of items agreed upon and yet to reach any bipartisan agreement in the latest legislative session.

water drain

Water main break floods 40-45 homes in St. Louis Park

The city says the rupture happened on Minnetonka Boulevard.

Eli Hart

Charges: 6-year-old Eli Hart shot up to 9 times by his mother

The 28-year-old is facing 2nd-degree murder charges.

dave lee wcco radio

Former WCCO Radio host Dave Lee moves into podcasts

His new podcast, called 'My First Concert,' launched last week.

Tow Boat

Tow boat collides with Mississippi River lock and dam in Alma, WI

The crash remains under investigation by the United States Coast Guard.

unsplash school bus

Police: Man in minivan approached kids, claimed he was former principal

Investigators say children were approached by a man in a white minivan who falsely claimed he'd been a local school principal.

covid

Minnesota's COVID-19 update for Monday, May 23

The latest from the state health department.

police tape, crime scene

Police: 2 people shot, 1 fatally over the weekend in La Crosse

Officers arrived to the scene and found one person suffering multiple gunshot wounds.

Bear killed after it attacked couple in Wisconsin.

Wisconsin couple fight, kill bear that broke into their home

The incident happened last week in north-central Wisconsin.

Image from iOS (2)

Urban Outfitters store in Uptown to close

A number of national chains have departed Uptown in recent years.

Screen Shot 2022-05-23 at 6.41.22 AM

USS Minneapolis-St. Paul officially launched in Duluth ceremony

It's the first U.S. Navy ship to be commissioned in Minnesota.

Related

The Tip Jar: 4 things millennials should be doing with their money

Just got a job and have no idea how to manage your money? These tips can set you up for the future.

The Tip Jar: Costco vs. Sam's Club, which is cheaper?

We also compared the 2 wholesalers' prices with a regular grocery store.

The Tip Jar: The best Pi Day discounts on pizzas, pies and gadgets

There are plenty of 3.14 related discounts and deals out there on 3/14.

The Tip Jar: Getting the Black Friday sales right

Full disclosure, I don't like Black Friday.

The Tip Jar: Ways to make extra cash with very little effort

Marketers will pay you to take surveys, watch TV, or go to a bar.