The Tip Jar: Should you tip on top of a service charge?

Opinion on the subject is divided.
Author:
Updated:
Original:

Do you tip when there's a service charge?

In some places, you don't get the choice of how much you tip, with restaurants adding a service charge of 18-20 percent to your bill – typically taking the form of a gratuity/tip added for parties of six or more.

But Minneapolis could see more restaurants add service charges for all diners – not just large groups – as it moves toward a $15-an-hour minimum wage.

Related: 

– The Tip Jar: Dining out? Here's when and how much you should tip

One thing to understand about a service charge: it generally goes to the restaurant, not the server. Some of the charge may well go towards paying that server's wages, but in all likelihood they're not getting the full amount as they would from a regular tip.

However in Minnesota, according to state laws, if a restaurant wants to keep the charge for itself, it must provide "clear and conspicuous notice" to customers on the menu, a placard or on the bill that the charge doesn't go to the server.

If this isn't made clear, then by law the service charge goes to your server – so you can count that as part of the tip you leave.

If the restaurant does make clear it's keeping the service charge, you will have to decide whether to leave extra money for the server. 

And opinion on whether you should or not is divided.

This guide on TripAdvisor says that tipping is not required when a service charge is added, and this debate on the same site seems to come to the same consensus (unless you're particularly pleased with the service you received).

But a discussion on Quora says it can depend on how much the service charge is. If there's a 15 percent service charge, you should consider topping it up by 5-10 percent.

What do you tip when you've used a coupon/gift card?

There's a bit more definitive etiquette on this question compared to the service charge debate: If you've used a coupon or gift card to reduce the cost of your meal, tip based on the full cost.

Related: 

– The Tip Jar: At a restaurant, should I tip pre- or post-tax?

Laura Barclay, of the Civility Center, told Tip Jar that tipping with coupons/gift cards involved can be confusing for diners, but you should figure out the cost before the discount.

So if your bill is $40, but reduced to $20 after using a gift card/coupon and you want to tip 20 percent – leave an $8 tip.

Same goes if you use a coupon for a buy-one-get-one-free meal – tip on the total amount of both meals.

But figure out your tip based on the pre-tax cost of the meal, she adds.

Next Up

D'Angelo Russell / Minnesota Timberwolves

The Timberwolves need more from D'Angelo Russell

The Wolves haven't gotten what they expected since making a blockbuster trade.

oct. 20 snow crash

Spinouts, crashes still happening after snow leaves MN roads a mess

The snow storm caused at least 208 crashes this weekend.

1024px-Crock_pot

For The Week: Food tips and tricks to get you through the next 7 days

BMTN's food writer Lindsay Guentzel makes life easier for Minnesotans.

snow, plow

Here's how much snow fell in Saturday's storm in Minnesota

MSP Airport had the highest total as of 7 a.m. Sunday with 5.3 inches.

Screen Shot 2021-01-18 at 3.17.49 PM

No KAT? No D'Lo? No problem as Timberwolves defeat Pelicans

The Timberwolves were without Karl-Anthony Towns and D'Angelo Russell, but still picked up a (SCORE) win.

Screen Shot 2021-01-23 at 7.53.44 PM

Spinouts, crashes across Twin Cities as snow gets heavier

There have been multiple incidents across the metro area.

Mason Branstrator

Family, friends raising funds for teen soccer standout with spinal injury

Mason Branstrator of Duluth was injured in a skiing accident.

Screen Shot 2021-01-22 at 9.08.16 PM

Tributes pour in after MN Supreme Court justice's daughter found dead

Olivia Chutich died near the campus of Iowa State University.

Image from iOS (96)

Early Saturday fire damages Burger King in Richfield

The fire was reported around 1:15 a.m. Saturday.

Jamal Mashburn Jr. / Gopher Basketball

Maryland hands Gophers first home loss of season

The 17th-ranked Gophers fell to the Terrapins 63-49 on Saturday afternoon.

Related

The Tip Jar: The best cheap eats at the Mall of America

If you're spending big in stores, the least you could do is save on food.

The Tip Jar: The best cheap eats at the Mall of America

If you're spending big in stores, the least you could do is save on food.

The Tip Jar: Should you accept Equifax's free credit lock offer?

A credit freeze or a fraud alert looks like a better bet.

The Tip Jar: Ways to make extra cash with very little effort

Marketers will pay you to take surveys, watch TV, or go to a bar.

The Tip Jar: Are air miles credit cards worth it?

And are they better than frequent flyer miles?

The Tip Jar: Dining out? Here's when and how much you should tip

Tipping can be a minefield – let us help you satisfy social conventions.