Skip to main content

To pursue or not to pursue: 15 percent of police chases led to crashes in 2012

  • Author:
  • Updated:

After a high-speed pursuit led to a deadly crash in downtown Minneapolis early Monday morning, family members of the 20-year-old victim questioned whether a police chase was necessary in the first place.

Yia Her, 34, of St. Paul was driving with a suspended license when he was pulled over on suspicion of speeding and drunken driving along I-94. Her sped off, prompting the chase

The pursuit continued into downtown, where Her ran a red light and slammed into the side of a car driven by Brady Sotona, killing him and critically injuring his passenger, 24-year-old Connor Macklin.

Her had a blood-alcohol level of 0.16 percent, twice the state's legal limit, and suffered non life-threatening injuries.

FOX 9 reports 15 percent of police chases led to an unintentional collision last year, which begs the question: are they worth it?

The statistics suggest that police think so.

Out of all pursuits, the suspect is captured 80 percent of the time and only 11 percent get away, FOX 9 reports. The remaining 9 percent of chases are called off by a supervisor because they're too dangerous.

However, the night of the deadly crash in downtown Minneapolis, a State Patrol supervisor was not on duty.

Neil Melton, executive director at the Minnesota Board of Peace Officer Standards and Training, said he believes having a second set of ears listening to the chase over a radio is "absolutely critical."

Hennepin County Attorney Mike Freeman says the officer behind the wheel is not to blame.

“I think the bottom line to me, this officer didn’t cause the death of the victim, Her caused it. And that’s why Her’s going to do big time," Freeman said in a Star Tribune report.

Her is charged with two felony counts of fleeing police in a vehicle, causing death or injury.

Next Up

Screen Shot 2022-01-24 at 11.21.49 AM

Alex Rodriguez: 'I'm not a Packers fan'

He was at Lambeau screaming "Cheese!" and "Let's go!" during the playoff game against the 49ers.

St. Paul Police Department

Woman killed in St. Paul's North End identified as 31-year-old

A 35-year-old man has been arrested in connection to the shooting.

police lights

Homes shot at randomly in Wisconsin; residents nearly struck

The people inside the homes were nearly struck, according to the  Juneau County Sheriff’s Office.

Levi Arneberg

Charges: Man killed roommate's 4 pet ferrets after argument

He told police he swears one of the ferrets was "laughing and breathing" as he kept shooting it in the head, charges state.

Minneapolis police

St. Cloud 27-year-old ID'd as victim of homicide near U of M

The shooting, which also injured two others, occurred Thursday near the 500 block of 15th Avenue South.


What happens to the Vikings if Aaron Rodgers leaves the NFC North?

Rodgers said he isn't interested in rebuilding in Green Bay, is it time for the Vikings to pounce or stay the course?


Sheriff: Men found unresponsive in garage died of cocaine overdose

Two of the three men found unresponsive in an Eyota garage last week died of a drug overdose, a preliminary autopsy found.


Watch: Police release chase video that ends in crash at playground

The June 2018 chase ended in a crash that injured three children.