Trump can halt funding used to help keep health insurance premiums low, judge says

The funds were put in place to help keep health plan costs affordable.

President Donald Trump's plan to cut off federal funds that were put in place to keep health premiums affordable for low-income Americans will move forward. 

U.S. District Judge Vince Chhabria on Wednesday said the elimination of these cost-sharing subsidies wouldn't have nearly as dramatic an impact as opponents to the cuts allege – so the White House can indeed stop them, as announced earlier this month

Seventeen attorneys general from across the U.S. – including Lori Swanson of Minnesota – joined together in a lawsuit to try to block the cuts. They argued it would mean more expensive health insurance for Americans buying through the Affordable Care Act.

But Chhabria didn't buy it (and even got a little snarky in his order), explaining their argument didn't acknowledge that tax credits for Americans will automatically increase if the cost of health insurance goes up. He also said many states have already comes up with plans to alleviate these cost increases.

Here's a snippet of his response:

"Why, in light of this discussion, have all these Attorneys General rushed to court seeking an emergency ruling against President Trump?
The primary reason offered by the states, and one they repeat over and over, is that premiums will go up for millions of people. But as already discussed, they are only able to make that argument sound compelling by omitting the fact that the premium increases in almost every state will cause tax credits to increase in a corresponding amount, leaving so many people (especially lower-income people) better off or unharmed."

You can see all the case documents here.

Chhabria was appointed to the district court seat by former President Barack Obama, by the way.

The effect on Minnesota

What are these cost-sharing subsidies? It's money the federal government paid to health insurance companies to keep premiums affordable for Americans.

In 2017 the estimated pay out was about $7 billion, CBS reported.

There is worry that getting rid of those payments will make health insurance more expensive for the people who benefited from them. That's what led to the lawsuit from the attorneys general of 18 states, plus Washington D.C. 

In Minnesota, things could be even more complicated because the state receives the payments – not insurance companies. The state then offers its own subsidized health plans under the MinnesotaCare program.

MinnesotaCare gets 85-95 percent of its funding from the federal government, of which $120 million comes from cost-sharing reductions – funding that could disappear as a result of Wednesday's order. 

Next Up

vaccine, covid

St. Paul care home group will mandate COVID vaccines for staff

It comes amid reports of COVID outbreaks at homes where residents are all vaccinated, but staff are not.

Jail handcuffs arrest

Starbuck man charged with uploading, sharing child pornography

The 47-year-old was arrested after a tip from the National Center of Missing and Exploited Children.


Boy, 11, seriously injured after 'fall' that police now suspect was abuse

It was initially reported that the boy slipped and fell.

police lights

Investigation underway after body found during welfare check in Plato

The identity of the deceased has not yet been revealed.

Mayor Brad Wiersum

'Please, please, please get vaccinated,' Minnetonka mayor pleads

This comes as the local state of emergency officially ends.

YouTube - Jeopardy screengrab minneapolis

Can you answer all the Minneapolis questions from this week's 'Jeopardy?'

KARE personalities including Randy Shaver and Rena Sarigianopoulos presented the clues.

Pexels - woman shop mask covid CROP

35 counties, including most of Twin Cities, now COVID hotspots

The CDC recommends everyone wear a mask in public, indoor places in these counties.

covid, coronavirus

CDC document: Delta variant as contagious as chickenpox

Vaccines remain very effective at preventing severe illness from the delta variant, however.

Flickr - smoke McGregor minnesota wildfire July 29 2021 - Lorie Shaull

'Unprecedented': The wildfire smoke isn't going anywhere this weekend

The air quality alert that was supposed to end Friday is now in effect into early next week.

Alexis Saborit

Charges: Woman killed in horrific Shakopee attack was trying to leave suspect

The shocking incident happened at an intersection Wednesday afternoon.

3M Open, Tony Finau

Multiple injuries after pickup crashes into shuttle bus at 3M Open

Blaine police listed 25 people as being involved in the collision.


Update: Help with health insurance costs is on the way

Not in the agreement? A proposal that would have let health insurance that doesn't meet Affordable Care Act requirements be sold in the state.

Will help be coming for 120K Minnesotans facing health insurance rate hikes?

Even the Department of Commerce said said there's an “urgent need” for reform.

Frustration with Trump administration brings Dayton and state Republicans together

Both are frustrated with poor communication from the Trump administration over health care funding.

Report: President's crucial decision on healthcare subsidies pushed back 3 months

The subsidies help people get affordable health plans through programs such as MinnesotaCare.

Politics in 2017: Trump and Dayton argue health care over Twitter

The president-elect and the governor of Minnesota, trading barbs on Twitter.