Skip to main content

Trump's own tweets listed as one reason the transgender military ban was blocked

Here's why the judge included the president's Twitter behavior as part of her ruling.

President Donald Trump's directive banning transgender Americans from serving in the U.S. military has been shut down by a federal judge.

And Trump's tweeting is one of the key reasons cited for the decision.

District Court Judge Colleen Kollar-Kotelly's opinion (published Monday) gave a win to the current and hopeful trans military members who filed the lawsuit against Trump and a number of military leaders

Kollar-Kotelly ruled the ban on accepting transgender individuals into the military (set to go into effect March 23, 2018), as well as the expulsion of current trans members from the armed services, won't be happening.

Related:

– Video: Meet the Minnesotan speaking out about being trans in the military

Judge Kollar-Kotelly listed a few key reasons for her decision – one of them being Trump's Twitter behavior.

'The discrimination in this case was certainly of an unusual character'

President Trump in July first announced his intentions to pursue this transgender ban on Twitter, without any additional explanation for how or why it might happen. 

It wasn't until a month later that the official presidential memorandum was released.

That loose tweeting is coming back to bite the president, with Kollar-Tokelly saying she considered the "circumstances" surrounding the announcement when weighing claims of discrimination. (Page 68 in the ruling.)

"The discrimination in this case was certainly of an unusual character," she wrote.

The ban announcement came "abruptly" via Twitter, she wrote, "without any of the formality or deliberative processes that generally accompany the development and announcement of major policy changes that will gravely affect the lives of many Americans."

That gives credence to the plaintiffs' argument that "the decision to exclude transgender individuals was not driven by genuine concerns regarding military efficacy," she continued.

Trump has not tweeted a response as of 3 p.m.

Earlier this month, when Trump's tweets were cited as a reason to again block proposed travel restrictions, as Quartz reported.

The tweets weren't the sole reason

Trump's prolific tweeting wasn't the only reason for Kollar-Kotelly's opinion.

There were two other key things she highlighted:

One, lawyers for the defendants (Trump and other military officials) argued that having trans service members would be costly or hurt "unit cohesion," and also said some transgender military members could have health issues that don't allow them to fulfill their duties.

Kollar-Kotelly debunked those, and wrote in part: "There is absolutely no support for the claim that the ongoing service of transgender people would have any negative effective on the military at all."

Two, she pointed to a study by the RAND National Defense Research Institute – endorsed by a Department of Defense Working Group – that concluded barring transgender individuals from serving would "undermine military effectiveness and readiness." In addition, the Army, Air Force and Navy all agreed allowing transgender persons to serve was fine. 

So the defendants' stated concerns – that it could negatively impact the armed forces – have "been studied and rejected by the military itself," she wrote.

What happens next?

For now, the official policy on transgender individuals serving in the U.S. military defaults to how it was before Trump's announcement – that there is no ban anymore, as announced by the Obama administration in June of 2016.

But this isn't a final ruling. 

The group suing the president however proved to have a strong enough case that it's likely they'll win – so Judge Kollar-Kotelly will not dismiss the case, as the defendants had asked her to do.

It will still have to go to trial for a final determination. No trial date has been set at this point, according to Bloomberg.

This opinion also leaves the door open for a policy change.

Kollar-Kotelly specifically said the process in which the ban was rolled out matters. If the president had asked for studies be done regarding transgender service in the military, and then issued the ban after those studies determined it would be beneficial, "this would be a different case," she wrote.

But that's not what happened here.

"At this time, it appears that the rights of a class of individuals were summarily and abruptly revoked for reasons contrary to the only then-available studies," the judge wrote.

Next Up

Parking lot of Plymouth Target

Police: 18-year-old woman carjacked outside Plymouth Target

The armed carjacking occurred just before 10 p.m. in the parking lot Wednesday.

PennLakeNotes

St. Paul man pleads guilty to robbing Penn Lake Roast Beef, shooting owner

Devon Dwyane Reginald Glover, 22, shot Kevan Tran during the June 2020 robbery.

James Robert Hess.

Charges: Man shot brother in the eye, let his body decompose in camper

James Robert Hess faces second-degree murder charges for the shooting death of his brother, William Harold Hess Jr.

Christopher Payne and Kaley Wethern

Coupled charged after $75k worth of fentanyl pills seized during traffic stop

Christopher James Payne and Kaley Maria Wethern have been charged in the seizure.

Screen Shot 2022-05-25 at 9.34.43 AM

Video: Plane with blown tire makes emergency landing at MSP Airport

An aviation enthusiast caught the moment on video.

Pixabay - laptop computer dark screen

St. Paul man charged in online 'sextortion' scheme targeting at least 500 girls

Yue Vang, 31, was charged in U.S. District Court Wednesday.

Great Dane Rescue and Sanctuary

Emaciated Great Danes rescued after being found living in minivan

Great Dane Rescue of Minnesota and Wisconsin posted that two of the dogs are in "rough condition" and "barely hanging on."

Screen Shot 2020-05-26 at 10.28.52 AM

2 years since George Floyd's killing, Biden signs exec order on policing

The signing comes on the second anniversary of Floyd's murder by police in south Minneapolis.

earlyseason

Lutsen Mountains owner to buy Michigan ski resort

The Skinner family has operated alpine ski areas in the Midwest for 60 years.

covid

Mayo Clinic, CDC address concerns over monkeypox in the US

The CDC does not currently think there is a significant threat to the general public.

police tape

Charges: Man killed brother, left body in homemade camper for 7 months

James Robert Hess, 48, faces second-degree murder charges for the death of his 52-year-old brother, William Harold Hess Jr.

Related

Trump's tweets about DACA and 'dreamers' used in court order blocking White House policy

Here's how the president's tweets about DACA and 'dreamers' came back to haunt him.

Minnesota Dems calling for transgender military ban reversal

143 House Democrats are asking President Trump to change course.

President Trump says transgender Americans can't serve in the military

He made the announcement on Twitter Wednesday morning.

The U.S. Supreme Court is letting Trump's travel ban go into effect – for now

The Supreme Court is letting the president's order go into effect – for now.

Minnesota mom won't give up lawsuit against her transgender teen

Anmarie Calgaro has filed an appeal after a judge dismissed her case.

SCOTUS reverses course, won't review #StandWithGavin transgender case

Gavin Grimm's efforts have inspired the #StandWithGavin hashtag.

Update: President Trump's new travel ban is also blocked by courts

A federal court put President Trump's revised travel ban on hold, just as courts did with the original one.