Skip to main content
Updated:
Original:

U.S. Supreme Court: Minneapolis man a 'frequent flyer' or 'frequent complainer'?

Author:

CNN reports the United States Supreme Court will hear oral arguments Tuesday in the case of a Minneapolis member of the former Northwest Airline's WorldPerks program. The case will be a test of consumer versus corporate rights.

The plaintiff is a former "frequent flier" whom the airline calls a "frequent complainer."

Rabbi Binyomin Ginsberg, former dean of Torah Academy in St. Louis Park, joined the Frequent Flier program in 1999 because he travels a lot for work. The rabbi writes parenting columns for several Jewish outlets and is the education director for Living Lessons. By 2005, he had attained Platinum Elite status.

But in June of 2008, Ginsberg claimed a Northwest representative called him to say his status was being revoked on grounds that he "abused" the program, according to court papers.

Ginsberg said the airline also took away the hundreds of thousands of miles accumulated in his account.

"It didn't make sense. Initially, when they contacted me on the phone I thought it was a prank call," Ginsberg told CNN. "When I pushed for a reason and clarification, they told me it was because I was complaining too much."

Northwest clarified its position in a letter a month later.

"You have continually asked for compensation over and above our guidelines. We have awarded you $1,925 in travel credit vouchers, 78,500 WorldPerks bonus miles, a voucher extension for your son, and $491 in cash reimbursements," the letter said. "Due to our past generosity, we must respectfully advise that we will no longer be awarding you compensation each time you contact us."

Aviation Magazine reported that Northwest Airlines believes it has a right to set its own policies, as a result of the Airline Deregulation Act 1978, which exposed passengers to market forces in the airline industry.

The Times of Israel reports Ginsberg filed a class-action lawsuit in January 2009 seeking $5 million against the airline in the United States District Court for the Southern District of California.

In an interview with  City Pages in August 2011, Ginsberg said, “This happened at the time that Northwest and Delta were merging. The suspicion was that they had too many frequent fliers at the higher status in their roll, and they were showing too much of a liability on a balance sheet for the accumulated miles by those passengers. So they had to creatively find ways of getting rid of people.”

But that court dismissed his claim, citing the ADA. On June 9, 2011, Ginsberg filed an appeal with the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit. In August, the court ruled in his favor.

Last spring the Supreme Court agreed to hear the case this term.

Next Up

Dalvin Cook

Report: Dalvin Cook has dislocated shoulder, will undergo MRI

The Vikings running back was carted off the field in Sunday's loss to the 49ers.

Kirk Cousins

Watch: Kirk Cousins lines up under guard on critical 4th down play

Kirk Cousins went "Full Kirk" at the worst possible time.

Dalvin Cook

Dalvin Cook injured, Vikings drop crucial game against 49ers

The Vikings couldn't stop the Niners' rushing attack in a 34-26 loss.

Flickr - police lights squad siren - Edward Kimmel

Man airlifted to a hospital after police shooting in Forest Lake

Police allege that the man presented a threat to officers.

Minnesota Wild

Wild's two third-period goals take down the Lightning

Ryan Hartman's go-ahead goal defeated the two-time defending champions.

Byron Buxton

Reports: Twins reach extension with Byron Buxton

The long-term deal locks in one of the Twins' franchise players.

Justin Jefferson

Vikings-49ers: 5 things you can count on

Sunday's matchup is a pivotal game in the NFC playoff picture.

Gopher Football

Watch: Gophers troll Badgers with 'Jump Around' after Saturday's win

First they took Paul Bunyan's Axe. Then they took their tradition.

Brandon Richart, missing person

Search underway for missing man in Anoka area

Brandon Richart was last seen Nov. 17.

U.S. Bank Stadium

5 teams win first state championships at Prep Bowl

A pair of records fell as the Prep Bowl lived up to the hype.

Related

Frequent flyer sues airline for taking his points because he filed complaints

S. Binyomin Ginsberg, of Minneapolis, claims the airline took away hundreds of thousands of miles he accumulated after making 24 complaints in less than a year. The suit was tossed out in 2009, but the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals is now reversing the decision.

Petters to request U.S. Supreme Court to review his case

The full Eighth Circuit Court of Appeals is denying convicted Minnesota businessman Tom Petters' request to re-hear his appeal. The Pioneer Press reports Petters will now ask the U.S. Supreme Court to review his case. He was found guilty in 2009 for orchestrating a $3.5 billion Ponzi scheme. The 54-year-old is currently serving a 50-year sentence at a federal penitentiary in Kansas.

U.S. Supreme Court won't review Tom Petters' fraud conviction

The Minnesota businessman had asked the nation's highest court to review his case. Petters was convicted on charges of orchestrating a $3.65 billion Ponzi scheme and is serving a 50-year prison sentence. His attorneys argued that the trial judge barred them from presenting evidence.