Skip to main content

Victory in the bag for new county commissioner as lucky draw settles tie vote

  • Author:
  • Updated:

The candidates campaigned hard through the election season. Then the Cook County auditor thought hard about the fairest way to randomly break the tie vote.

On Monday the winner of the District 1 seat on the county board of commissioners was finally settled when Frank Moe pulled a lucky red game piece out of a cloth bag custom-made for the occasion, the Star Tribune reports. His opponent, Kristin DeArruda Wharton, was left with the blue piece signifying a runner-up finish.

The results of last week's election showed each candidate received 246 votes as they vied to represent the northeasternmost part of Minnesota.

After the outcome was settled by Monday's random drawing at the courthouse in Grand Marais, a subsequent recount requested by Wharton confirmed the tie, MPR News reports.

Game pieces rather than Scrabble tiles

Under Minnesota law, when elections end in a tie the winner is to be chosen "by lot."

That gives cities and counties leeway to chose whatever random method they prefer, such as flipping a coin, pulling a name from a hat, or drawing cards from a deck. An August primary race among city council candidates in Rosemount was the state's most recent example of a tie being randomly settled – in that case by a coin flip.

County Auditor Braidy Powers tells the Star Tribune he worried a coin toss might go awry if he got nervous and didn't like the idea of tracking a rolling coin into a corner to see how it landed. He first planned on having the candidates pull Scrabble tiles from a bag – whoever pulls a Z wins – but was advised that it's possible to discern a letter by touch, the Star Tribune says.

Ultimately Powers found two identical red and blue pieces from a board game at home and brought them to the courthouse to be pulled from a bag a staff member had hand-sewn for the occasion, the newspaper reports.

The Cook County News Herald notes that another of the county board races on last week's ballot was decided by a margin of just five votes. But the paper says that one did not meet the criteria for a recount at county expense, as the District 1 race did.

Next Up

Screen Shot 2022-12-03 at 4.35.18 PM

Watch: New London-Spicer wins 3A championship on incredible walk-off TD

New London-Spicer defeated the unbeaten Dilworth-Glyndon-Felton in remarkable circumstances.


Suspect in woman's killing in Moorhead is arrested

James Kollie Jr. was arrested Friday evening.

Jennifer Carnahan

Former chair Jennifer Carnahan sues Minnesota GOP, which is suing her back

Carnahan stepped down under a cloud of controversy in August 2021.

Minneapolis Fire Department

One injured after leaping from burning vacant building in Minneapolis

Authorities say the building is known to be used by squatters.


Head-on crash leaves two drivers dead in southeastern Minnesota

The crash happened in Houston County just before 4 p.m. Friday.


Charges: Armed man made death threats at Minneapolis LGBTQ bar

The man allegedly used derogatory terms while threatening to kill someone.


FDA pulls last COVID-19 monoclonal antibody treatment as new variants rise

A therapy used to treat more than 11,000 Minnesotans is no longer authorized amid a surge in the latest COVID-19 variants.

Austin Robert LeClaire

Charges: Plymouth man shot girlfriend in head after birthday party

The 23-year-old victim is in critical condition as of Friday.


State announces $2.5M in grants for child care providers

Child care providers in roughly a dozen communities will receive funds to help grow the supply of affordable, quality child care.


Probe of Golden Valley police uncovers racism, alleged misconduct

One officer was terminated for alleged racist comments and violations of state law.

blowing snow

Blowing snow Friday in Minnesota; will it snow next week?

Winds could gust up to 50 mph Friday afternoon and night.

Deer hunting blaze orange

To combat CWD, late-season deer hunting announced for 9 areas of MN

The special hunts will be held between Dec. 16 and 18.