Skip to main content

Stunner: Voter ID amendment fails

In a shocking upset, the voter ID amendment has failed, and by a sizable margin. With 98 percent of precincts reporting, the "no" votes led by nearly 8 percentage points, MPR says. The measure would have amended the state constitution to require voters to bring photo IDs to the polls.
  • Author:
  • Updated:

In a shocking upset, the voter ID amendment has failed, and by a sizable margin, MPR reports. With 98.6 percent of the vote counted, 53.8 percent had voted "no" and 46.2 voted yes, MPR says.

It was a surprising turn-around: Through much of the campaign season, polls suggested the amendment would pass.

But amendment supporters knew as midnight approached Tuesday that it did not look good for the amendment. They were taking down signs and cleaning up after a gathering at O'Gara's tavern in St. Paul shortly before midnight, MPR reported.

"There aren't enough votes there to turn it around," Dan McGrath of Protect My Vote told MPR. The leader of the pro-amendment campaign vowed to push for a voter ID law in the Legislature.

At issue was the ballot measure that asked voters if the state should create a constitutional amendment that would require voters to bring a photo identification to the polls.

The Republican-backed proposal was part of a national push by Republicans to tighten up voting systems at the state level, the Star Tribune notes. The Minnesota battle was completely partisan – Republican state lawmakers supported it and DFLers opposed it.

Throughout the campaign season, polls showed that the voter ID amendment had the support of a majority of Minnesotans, although polls just a few days before the election showed it could be very close.

Supporters of the amendment said it was needed to prevent fraud and protect the integrity of voting in Minnesota.

Critics said the amendment is an expensive answer to a problem that doesn't exist, given that there have been no cases of people being prosecuted in Minnesota for voter impersonation or double voting. Cost estimates for the amendment range from $1 million to $50 million. Critics also say the amendment was a cynical play by a Republican legislature to lower Democratic voter turnout. That's because 84,000 people are registered to vote but have no ID, and more of them are left-leaning: elderly, college students, and the poor. Critics have also said the issue should be handled in state law because ID technology is rapidly changing, and laws are much easier to update than the constitution.

Whether voter fraud is a myth or real problem is complicated question.

The Legislature would have to sort out the details on how photo ID will work. Among the questions: What kind of ID will be accepted? What happens if voters don’t have one? How much it would cost and who pays?

Next Up

Screen Shot 2022-09-25 at 6.09.38 PM

Parkland shooting survivor David Hogg to headline Duluth rally

The rally will take place at Leif Erikson Park on Oct. 1.

Screen Shot 2022-09-26 at 6.09.43 AM

Stella's Fish Cafe closes temporarily to investigate viral rodent video

The Uptown restaurant said it was closing temporarily so it could investigate the claims.

Governor Tim Walz

Walz, judge in dispute over Feeding Our Future case

A Ramsey County judge disputed Walz's claims that the Minnesota Department of Education was ordered by the court to resume payments to Feeding Our Future.


2 dead, 1 with life-threatening injuries in Hwy. 7 crash

Both drivers were not wearing their seatbelt, according to the State Patrol.

Screen Shot 2022-09-25 at 11.50.33 AM

15-year-old Richfield football game shooting suspect arrested

A 16-year-old accused of instigating the altercation is also in custody.

Police tape

3 arrested after homicide, burglary in Inver Grove Heights

Charges of first-degree murder and first-degree burglary are pending.

fire, firefighter

Woman dies after becoming trapped in Waseca house fire

Police tried to enter the home but heavy smoke prevented them from getting inside.


1 dead, 2 with life-threatening injuries in Minnesota crash

The crash happened just after 7:30 p.m. Friday.

Image (1)

School bus carrying students plunges into river southwest of Fargo

None of the kids suffered life-threatening injuries, though some were taken to area hospitals.

Richfield High School

Richfield High School cancels weekend events after shooting

Two men were shot outside the school's football stadium

Screen Shot 2022-09-23 at 10.21.38 PM

Sound of shots, mass panic at Richfield football game streamed live on YouTube

Gunfire caused panic at a varsity football game Friday night.


Plenty of questions to be answered if Voter ID amendment passes

Estimates of how much it will cost to implement a voter ID requirement at Minnesota polling places range from a few million dollars to $100 million. The cost is among many details that state lawmakers will need to fill in if residents approve a Constitutional amendment requiring a government-issued ID to vote.

Voter ID amendment headed for November ballot

Minnesotans will vote this fall on a Constitutional amendment that would make a photo ID a requirement to vote. The Republican-backed measure passed the Legislature on party-line votes. Now supporters and critics of the change will ramp up campaigns to influence the public.

ACLU leads challenge to voter ID amendment

The Minnesota Supreme Court heard arguments Tuesday afternoon in a lawsuit aimed at keeping the voter ID constitutional amendment off of the statewide ballot. The American Civil Liberties Union of Minnesota, League of Women Voters Minnesota and other anti-amendment groups are asking the court to strike down the ballot question. They claim its wording is too vague and misleading.

Voter ID amendment advances at Capitol

Proposals for a constitutional amendment requiring photo IDs at polls are just a step away from reaching the House and Senate floors, MinnPost reports. Constitutional amendments, if approved by the Legislature, go straight to voters. They do not require Gov. Dayton's signature, so he cannot veto them.

Republicans introduce bill to implement voter ID through amendment

A group of Republican senators have introduced a bill that would have voters decide a controversial election reform measure this fall. Introducing a voter ID requirement as an amendment to the state constitution means the measure would bypass a threatened veto from Democratic Gov. Dayton.

Polls find dead heat in Marriage Amendment, edge for Voter ID support

Two new Minnesota Polls by the Star Tribune find a statistical dead head in the constitutional amendment to ban same-sex marriage, but a slight edge for support of a constitutional change that would require voters to show a government-issued photo ID.

Critics of Voter ID amendment to court: Legislature is misleading voters

Groups that are challenging the proposed Constitutional amendment that would require an ID to vote filed paperwork with the Minnesota Supreme Court in advance of the hearing later this month. They say if the court approves the ballot question as is, it will send the message that the Legislature is free to mislead or deceive voters.

Voter ID amendment clears first hurdle in state Senate

The Senate Local Government and Elections Committee passed the voter ID bill on a party-line vote, with DFLers opposing it. The measure has several more stops before it would appear on the November ballot as a proposed Constitutional amendment.