Skip to main content

Warrants issued for Otter Tail Co. couple accused of mistreating horses


Authorities are looking for two of three people charged with several counts of animal mistreatment after nearly a dozen horses were found malnourished or dead in Otter Tail County.

KBRF-AM reports 47-year-old Bill Karl Fick, 38-year-old Penny Lynn Fick and 19-year-old Billy Vance Tompkins failed to show up to a scheduled court appearance on May 6.

Tompkins was arrested Friday morning while Bill and Penny Fick, both of whom are facing 21 criminal counts, are still on the loose, according to the radio station.

The Otter Tail County sheriff's office, along with the Humane Society and High Tail Ranch and Rescue, were called to a property in rural Vergas last February for a report of animal neglect.

KBRF reports six horses were found dead. Two were thought to be near death and three others were found laying down--all appeared lethargic, dehydrated and thin.

According to WDAY, several surviving horses and three llamas were rescued, recuperated and put up for adoption.

WDAY has video.

Next Up

West St Paul, Minnesota - August 2018

Female shot in parking lot of Twin Cities Menards store

The incident happened at the same Menards where a robbery happened in September.

Image from iOS

1 injured, 1 in custody following shooting, police chase in Hopkins

The suspect was arrested following a police pursuit Sunday afternoon.

Kirk Cousins

Kirk Cousins surprises Viking fan van on Minnesota highway

Cousins's new aggressiveness has pulled into the fast lane.

Joel Eriksson Ek

Another Wild rally falls short against Lightning

The Wild scored two goals with the extra attacker but couldn't beat the two-time defending champs.

police tape, crime scene

2 shootings in Brooklyn Park under investigation

Both incidents remain under investigation.

Justin Jefferson

Justin Jefferson erupts to lead Vikings over Packers

Greg Joseph's game-winner helped the Vikings get back to .500.

Duluth fire department, fire engine, fire truck

Officials investigating Duluth apartment fire that displaced 10 people

The fire broke out Friday night on the 600 block of East 4th Street.

Car break-in, smashed window, car theft

Orono police alert residents after series of 'smash and grab' robberies

The thieves are targeting cars and stealing valuables left inside.

Adam Thielen

Vikings vs. Packers: 5 things you can count on

Can the Vikings win a pivotal divisional battle?


Man killed in shooting outside apartment building in St. Paul

Shots fired were reported to police around 11:30 p.m.

Anthony Edwards

Ant sets the tone, Timberwolves dominate Grizzlies

The Wolves have won four of their past six games.


police lights

Horse fatally shot in rural Otter Tail County

The animal was in a pasture with other horses when it was shot.