What's the Twins' optimal batting order? Here are 3 ideas

As Spring Training draws closer, excitement for baseball season is building.
Author:
Updated:
Original:

Baseball is almost back with the Twins reporting to spring training Feb. 15. While the pitching staff will control the headlines, the batting order manager Paul Molitor goes with will probably have to carry the team.

Not so fun fact: The Twins used 148 different batting orders last season, according to Baseball Reference. No batting order was used more than three times. For perspective, the AL champion Cleveland Indians employed 101 different lineups.

Brian Dozier, fresh off 42 homers and a ton of trade rumors, leads a lineup with a ton of potential as Miguel Sano, Byron Buxton, Eddie Rosario, Max Kepler and Jorge Polanco hope to take the lineup to the next level. Here are three lineups that make sense, at least in our GoMN baseball minds.

Joe Nelson's optimal lineup:

  1. Jorge Polanco - SS
  2. Joe Mauer - 1B
  3. Miguel Sano - 2B
  4. Brian Dozier - 3B
  5. Max Kepler - RF
  6. Kennys Vargas - DH
  7. Byron Buxton - CF
  8. Jason Castro - C
  9. Eddie Rosario - LF

Highlight of the lineup: This lineup puts the most productive hitter in the t spot, where Dozier had an outstanding .606 slugging percentage last season. The bulk of his homers came as a leadoff hitter, but imagine how many RBI he could finish with if he's at the dish with men on base.

Ideally, Buxton is the leadoff hitter but he has a lot to prove this spring. Additionally, Polanco's strikeout rate (17 percent) was a lot lower than Buxton's (35.6 percent). It's critical that Minnesota gets the leadoff man right for the simple fact that 30 of Dozier's 42 homers last season were solo shots. He needs men on base.

Aaron Ziemer's optimal lineup:

  1. Byron Buxton – CF
  2. Joe Mauer – 1B
  3. Brian Dozier – 2B
  4. Miguel Sano – 3B
  5. Max Kepler – RF
  6. Kennys Vargas – DH
  7. Jason Castro – C
  8. Eddie Rosario – LF
  9. Jorge Polanco – SS

Highlight of the lineup: While on the surface it makes more sense for the Twins to lead off with Polanco, it's time for Buxton to put up or sit down. There were some signs he's ready to produce. Buxton slashed .287/.357/.653 with 9 home runs, 22 RBIs, and 24 runs over his final 29 games, in September. It's time to see if he can do it when it matters most.

Dozier is now Minnesota's best hitter period. He gets the No. 3 spot, I'd consider dropping Mauer to 6 or even 7, if Polanco or Rosario look ready for the 2 spot.

Declan Goff's optimal lineup:

  1. Byron Buxton - CF
  2. Robbie Grossman - DH
  3. Joe Mauer - 1B
  4. Miguel Sano - 3B
  5. Brian Dozier 2B
  6. Max Kepler - RF
  7. Eddie Rosario - LF
  8. Jason Castro - C
  9. Jorge Polanco - SS

Highlight of the lineup:

Even though Mauer's batting average has declined, his OBP (.363) is still too good to not have near the top of the lineup. Same goes for Grossman who led the team with a .386 percentage last season. With those two getting on base, you can expect a ton of RBI for Sano and Dozier.

With the Twins not having a lot of speed in the top half of their lineup, they'll need Buxton in the leadoff spot. Plus with the way he finished last season, he deserves it. Which is also the spot he's held down for the majority of his time in the minors.

Next Up

Minneapolis police

Vehicle runs over 2 people in downtown Minneapolis brawl

Two suspects have reportedly been identified.

Jorge Alcala

Rare night for Twins' bullpen fuels victory over Cardinals

The Twins scored five runs in the third inning in an 8-1 victory.

Bisi Johnson

Report: Bisi Johnson tears ACL, will miss 2021 season

Johnson suffered the injury during Friday's practice.

Mike Zimmer

Frustrated Zimmer sounds off after Vikings' positive COVID test

"I’m frustrated, not just with my football players who didn’t get vaccinated, but I’m frustrated with everybody [who didn't]."

Kirk Cousins

Report: Kellen Mond has COVID, Cousins among players out of practice

The team is scheduled to practice on Saturday night.

USPS packages

Two Ramsey County men sentenced in mail theft scheme

Sonny Vang Xiong was sentenced to three years in prison, while Davis Her was sentenced to six and a half years in prison.

Jeff Gladney

Jeff Gladney's ex-girlfriend files $1 million civil lawsuit

The civil lawsuit accuses Gladney of assaulting the woman for over two hours.

vaccine, covid

St. Paul care home group will mandate COVID vaccines for staff

It comes amid reports of COVID outbreaks at homes where residents are all vaccinated, but staff are not.

Jail handcuffs arrest

Starbuck man charged with uploading, sharing child pornography

The 47-year-old was arrested after a tip from the National Center of Missing and Exploited Children.

ambulance

Boy, 11, seriously injured after 'fall' that police now suspect was abuse

It was initially reported that the boy slipped and fell.

Related

What's the Twins' optimal batting order? Here are 3 ideas

As Spring Training draws closer, excitement for baseball season is building.

Twins batting order: Dozier leading off? Buxton batting 3rd?

It looks like Paul Molitor is thinking about letting Byron Buxton bat third.

Twins batting order: Dozier leading off? Buxton batting 3rd?

It looks like Paul Molitor is thinking about letting Byron Buxton bat third.

It's looking more likely that Mauer will bat 4th for the Twins

It's looking more and more likely that the middle of the Twins' order will feature Buxton, Mauer and Sano.

It's looking more likely that Mauer will bat 4th for the Twins

It's looking more and more likely that the middle of the Twins' order will feature Buxton, Mauer and Sano.

Nelson Cruz

Here's the Twins' batting order for Game 1

Eddie Rosario is batting fourth and starting in right field.

Byron Buxton

Should the Twins move Buxton up in the batting order?

Buxton's finally having a breakout season at the plate.