America's Best Hockey Towns? A 'study' that Minnesotans will hate


For the first time in recorded history, a so-called study claims there are nine American cities that are better hockey towns than any city in the State of Hockey.

A company called "smartasset" created a criteria that somehow established a hockey town pecking order like this (only cities with a team in the NHL, East Coast Hockey League, American Hockey League or Division 1 college hockey were eligible).

  1. Grand Forks, North Dakota
  2. Hanover, New Hampshire
  3. Lewiston, New York
  4. Glens Falls, New York
  5. Houghton, Michigan
  6. Hershey, Pennsylvania
  7. Fairbanks, Alaska
  8. Marquette, Michigan
  9. Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania
  10. Duluth, Minnesota

Grand Forks is the home of the University of North Dakota, so seeing them ranked so high is nothing to laugh at. But the rest of this list, Minnesotans will agree, is a bit crazy.

How did they come up with this?

The criteria will help make some sense of it – even if the reasoning behind the criteria is sort of senseless.

It was broken down into two parts: "Quality of Life Score" and "Fan-Intensity Score."

The Quality of Life Score is determined by looking at some crime and employment statistics.

Fan-Intensity Scores were established by looking at the average attendance for a game, based on the town's population, and some Google search traffic numbers.

The example for the attendance part of the equation is that Grand Forks has an attendance rate of 20 percent because, of the 53,000 people in Grand Forks, an average of 10,000 people attend UND games.

This assumes all people at a game are from the town (which is unlikely). And gives a serious disadvantage to a town the larger its population is.

Anyway, Duluth was the top-rated Minnesota city, followed by Bemidji (18th), St. Paul (20th), Mankato (21st) and St. Cloud (23rd).

For a friendlier-to-Minnesota list of awesome hockey towns, check out this Bleacher Report list from 2012. Faribault, Duluth and Minneapolis-St. Paul made the cut, with one of them in the top five.

Next Up

Screen Shot 2021-04-22 at 4.12.50 PM

For The Week: Making cocktails at home? Here's how to do it right

Lindsay Guentzel's For The Week column features simple food and drink tips.

coronavirus, covid-19

Mayo Clinic study provides 'best guess' about pandemic's future in MN

Minnesota could be seeing decreasing numbers into the summer if the study is correct.

daunte wright funeral - siblings

Mourners remember Daunte Wright, plead for justice

Wright was killed by a now-former Brooklyn Center police officer on April 11.


HealthPartners: COVID hospitalizations driven by unvaccinated, middle aged adults

The health provider says the average age of its hospitalized patients is trending downwards.

Andrew Thomas booking photo

Man suspected of shooting at National Guard in Minneapolis faces more charges

He has now been charged in Hennepin County District Court with more serious crimes.


Investigation finds EPA mishandled oversight for PolyMet mine permits

A new report found the EPA didn't follow its own procedures when it submitted comments on the proposed project.


MDH's new COVID guidance urges weekly testing for those involved in sports

Those not involved in school sports are still advised to get tested every two weeks.

Trey Lance

With loaded QB draft class, now is the time for Vikings to act

With a strong class, this year might be the time to select Kirk Cousins' successor.

Kellen Mond

Coller: Is a 'developmental' quarterback worth it?

Matthew Coller writes a weekly Vikings column for BMTN, with more of his work found at Purple Insider.