Cowherd makes a case that Peterson is the most overrated NFL star of the last decade

Based on the numbers, is it hard to argue with what Cowherd is saying?
Author:
Updated:
Original:

Colin Cowherd gets paid to formulate big opinions, and he did exactly that this week when he called Adrian Peterson the NFL's most overrated star in the last decade. 

Here's his direct quote, courtesy of Fox Sports

"I've said this for years about Adrian Peterson. He's the most overrated NFL star in a decade. He didn't translate to wins, but he was so powerful. And his big runs were so, were so Porsche-like. It was so dynamic that you forgot that he couldn't block, he couldn't catch, he didn't practice, had off field issues, and fumbled a ton."

... continued ... 

"Off field issues, fumbling issues, can't catch, wasn't particularly deft at blocking-- didn't want to practice at the end of his career. If you stacked up Adrian Peterson and Tiki Barber's careers, they're actually pretty close. But you think of Peterson as a rockstar. And Tiki Barber quit the sport."

Cowherd isn't wrong about Peterson's fumbling problems. In 10 seasons (eight, really) he's fumbled 42 times (including playoffs) and lost 29 of them, according to Football Reference

As for the Tiki Barber comparison, let's take a look (Barber played 10 seasons). 

Barber fumbled more and was clearly a better receiver, but Peterson has found the end zone nearly twice as often as Barber did.

You be the judge. I'm going to go out on a limb here and say Peterson > Barber, and it ain't that close. 

Next Up

Hennepin County Government Center

Some Hennepin County Government Center services will be unavailable during Chauvin's trial

Access to the building will be limited during the trail, which begins March 8.

Street sweeper

Driver, 19, killed in collision with street sweeper

It happened Thursday evening near Thief River Falls.

famous dave's

Famous Dave's to launch its first 'line service' restaurant in the Twin Cities

The new model of restaurant will open in September in Coon Rapids.

State Capitol.

Minnesota's budget outlook improves, now projecting $1.6B surplus

The state was projecting a $1.3 billion deficit in November.

warroad ice road

2.5 mile skating path through Warroad was a hit, now there's an effort to keep it

The "Riverbender Crew" is hoping to buy new equipment to maintain the path this season, and for years to come.

Screen Shot 2021-02-26 at 10.10.55 AM

Officers identified in fatal shooting of suspect in Isanti County

Three officers were identified in the police chase that ended with one suspect being shot and a police dog being injured.

House for sale

Zillow to start making offers on Twin Cities homes based off its 'Zestimates'

The Twin Cities property market is seriously hot right now.

Hennepin County Medical Center, HCMC

Man killed in early morning crash on Minneapolis' Cedar Avenue

Minneapolis police responded to the crash at 2600 Cedar Avenue South early Friday morning.

ambulance

2 killed in separate incidents in Minneapolis hours apart Thursday

One man was killed in a triple shooting, the other fatally stabbed in an apparent domestic incident.

Screen Shot 2021-02-26 at 10.13.27 AM

'Dangerous situation' in Duluth, public asked to stay away after suspect kills K9

It started on Thursday evening and has continued into Friday.

Related

Adrian Peterson

Peterson, Patterson make NFL's All-Decade team

Peterson was one of eight unanimous selections while Patterson made it as a kick returner.

Adrian Peterson trolls fan about NFL Network's Top 100 of 2017

Adrian Peterson got a little bit cocky with a fan on Instagram.

Adrian Peterson trolls fan about NFL Network's Top 100 of 2017

Adrian Peterson got a little bit cocky with a fan on Instagram.