Digesting the Draft: How the Vikings did, according to the experts


There's no doubt that the NFL has become a passing league and the Vikings acknowledged the fact by drafting a wide receiver – Laquon Treadwell – in the first round and a cornerback – Mackenzie Alexander – in the second round.

The rest of the picks were:

  • Kentrell Brothers, linebacker
  • Willie Beavers, tackle/guard
  • Moritz Boehringer, wide reciver
  • David Morgan, tight end
  • Stephen Weatherly, defensive end/linebacker
  • Jayron Kearse, safety

We've compiled the draft grades given to the Vikings by seven respectable writers/outlets and here they are.

Sports Illustrated's Doug Farrar: B

"The addition of Laquon Treadwell in the first round gives Teddy Briddgewater the kind of big, aggressive receiver he hasn't yet had with his NFL team. Size issues with Treadwell are overblown, and he should succeed. And second-round cornerback Mackensie Alexander is a great value with the ability to play outside and in the slot. Of course, the big story of the Vikings' class is the fifth-round selection of Moritz Boehringer, who previously played with the Schwäbisch Hall Unicorns of the German Football League. Boehringer , who’s the first draft pick to come from straight out of Europe, got into football a few years back after watching new teammate Adrian Peterson on YouTube. He has the base athleticism to make it in the NFL, and now comes the task of learning advanced routes and dealing with NFL competition. Western Michigan tackle Willie Beavers could also be a standout in this class in time. Like T.J. Clemmings, last year's developmental offensive lineman, Beavers has a lot of talent, and a lot of learning to do. Also, keep an eye on Vanderbilt end Stephen Weatherly. —DF"

Sports Illustrated went further, saying Treadwell was one of the two best steals in the first round.

This embed is invalid

FOX Sports' Peter Schrager: C

"I'm not nearly as high on Laquon Treadwell as others and actually think the Vikings were probably a little frustrated to see the run on receivers right before them in the draft. Treadwell could work well alongside Stefon Diggs, but I'm not sure he was worthy of the 23rd overall pick when there may have been some value had the team looked to trade back a few slots. I'm also not as high on Mackensie Alexander, the second-round cornerback who didn't record a single interception during his college career. Moritz Boehringer, the German project, was a cute story. But is he helping you get over the hump next year? Then again, if any coach can get the most of his players, it's Mike Zimmer."

NFL.com's Chad Reuter: A

"General manager Rick Spielman got the most physical receiver in the draft in Treadwell. There's no reason he won't be a to-go guy for Teddy Bridgewater. Alexander is an excellent defender, even without the turnover production. Then Spielman picked up two 2017 mid-round selections from Miami. That's building draft capital.

Spielman found quality players in Beavers, Brothers, Weatherly, and Morgan. Kearse was worth a shot in the seventh round. Boehringer's upside is highly intriguing."

Sporting News: A

"Rick Spielman, Mike Zimmer and Norv Turner have an amazing mindmeld going on right now with a playoff team that's ready to win big now. Let's start with offense. Treadwell is the perfect all-around receiver to pair with last year's speedy steal, Stephon Diggs. Boehringer, the Randy Moss of Germany, has stud potential, and Morgan has great receiving upside, too. Beavers is a swingman who can start in 2017. Defensively, Zimmer got another scrappy corner in stealing Alexander. Brothers and Weatherly pile on their linebacker domination with Anthony Barr and Eric Kendricks. It's the kind of draft that helps them turn the corner toward real NFC title contention."

CBS Sports' Pete Prisco: B-

"The Vikings hit it right by getting Treadwell, and Alexander is a talent. Willie Beavers in the fourth round adds line depth and Brothers is a player who could make an immediate impact."

Bleacher Report: A

"Laquon Treadwell is the next Dez Bryant. Mackensie Alexander is a huge steal at No. 54, and the Vikings made an interesting choice in Round 6 with German receiver Moritz Boehringer. It'll be a storyline worth following."

USA Today's Lindsay Jones: A

"It’s hard to find fault with any of the early draft picks. Mississippi WR Laquon Treadwell fills a need on offense and should be a nice complement to Stefon Diggs, while Clemson CB Mackensie Alexander could contribute immediately in nickel packages. The most surprising pick came Saturday afternoon in German WR Moritz Boehringer, who is the first European player drafted into the NFL without playing in the NCAA."

Next Up


19-year-old dies in ATV crash; 1 charged for providing alcohol to a minor

The 19-year-old from Buffalo died in the crash Oct. 9.

dayton's project

Opening date for revamped Dayton's building revealed

It will open with a maker's market featuring 30 local vendors selling various goods.


Driver, 25, crashes into stoplight in Bemidji and dies

Preliminary figures show there have been 379 deaths on Minnesota roads this year.

Bob Brink

Legendary Minnesota high school basketball coach Bob Brink dies

Brink's 936 wins are second-most in state history.

northern lights

Pictures: Skywatchers treated to spectacular northern lights show in MN

The aurora borealis was visible as far south as Iowa overnight.

718 W Broadway Ave, Minneapolis, Minnesota - July 2019

SUV driver kills woman on mobility scooter, flees scene

The white SUV involved in the hit-and-run "will have significant damage to the front," according to police.

police lights

Man in custody after shooting at police near high school in Oakdale

Police fired back, but no one was hurt by gunfire.

Bashaud Breeland

Mike Zimmer says Bashaud Breeland tweet wasn't aimed at fans

The Vikings cornerback sent the tweet after Sunday's win over the Lions.

Devondre Trevon Phillips (left), pictured in 2012, and Terry Lorenzo Brown (right), pictured in 2020.

Murder charges in food hall mass shooting reveal details from chaotic scene

Two people face a dozen felonies apiece in connection with the deadly shootout.

Mischief Toy Store - Facebook

MN toy store responds to 1-star review over mask requirement

"If that's not OK with you then please don't come back," the toy store wrote.

Screen Shot 2021-10-10 at 7.07.37 AM

After mass shooting, food truck hall will 'remain closed in the coming days'

The St. Paul business posted an update Monday afternoon.

Screen Shot 2021-10-11 at 2.59.25 PM

Zimmer on Cousins: 'He kind of gave me a shove and I shoved him back'

Just two football guys doing football things, apparently.