Super Bowl revenue of $500 million? Economists say no


Minnesota officially unveiled its bid to host Super Bowl 52 Monday in a morning news conference at the Capitol, one of the money quotes coming from Gov. Mark Dayton when he stated hosting could generate a $500 million uptick in the state's economy.

According to multiple economists, those estimates are a little off.

Speaking to the Star Tribune's Jon Tevlin, Victor Matheson, a professor of economics at the College of Holy Cross that has studied economic impact of large events on the host city, says the NFL has been inflating profit figures for decades when it comes to Super Bowl figures.

“The NFL magically comes up with a number that corresponds roughly to what a city just spent on stadium subsidies. A Super Bowl is certainly a good thing for a city. But not nearly as good as they pretend.”

Matheson said the actual economic spike for a city hosting the NFL's title game is anywhere from $30-120 million.

Other economists seem even less optimistic on the high end.

Robert Baade, a professor at Lake Forest College who has focused his studies specifically on the Super Bowl's economic impact on host cities, says rather than $500 million, the decimal point should take a step to the left.

Baade spoke to CBS on the projected impact of the Super Bowl on this year's host, New York:

“The NFL says $500 or $600 million? I think $50 to $60 million would be a generous appraisal of what the Super Bowl generates.”

One of the main things both experts agree on when it comes to the NFL and Dayton's estimates, is that they fail to take into account that much of the money spent during Super Bowl week in the host city is dropped at NFL sponsored events, meaning the cash goes right back into the league's pocket.

Matheson also notes that the "substitution effect", which refers to consumers spending money on NFL events RATHER THAN their normal small business spendings locally, as a discrepancy in the NFL's figures and realistic estimates.

More examples debunking the large figures that have been bandied about appear here,here, and here.

Next Up

Governor Tim Walz

Walz will announce timeline 'to end all COVID-19 restrictions'

The details will be revealed in the governor's planned Thursday address.

Associate wearing PPE 2

Amazon to open new facility in St. Cloud this year, creating 'hundreds' of jobs

St. Cloud Mayor Dave Kleis shared the news in his State of the City address this week.

State Patrol

State Patrol: Semi driver kills self after being stopped by troopers

The incident happened Wednesday morning in the Miracle Mile shopping center parking lot in Rochester.

state fair beer

Money Gal: Don't forget the most important items in your budget

Kelly started Money Gal Coaching after paying down more than $46,000 in debt in just 20 months.


Crash kills motorcyclist near Treasure Island casino

The crash took place just before midnight.

The Lunds & Byerlys on Cedar Avenue in Minneapolis, three weeks prior to opening.

New Lunds & Byerlys opens in Minneapolis this month

It's been built in the spot formerly occupied by Bergan's SuperValu.

valleyfair food workers 1

Valleyfair food workers getting a pay raise for 2021 season

The starting wage will increase from $11.25 an hour to $15 an hour.

Screen Shot 2021-05-05 at 11.10.59 AM

Peloton recalls treadmills after child's death, dozens of other injuries

Officials say owners should stop using them immediately.

Screen Shot 2020-05-29 at 6.42.54 AM

St. Paul man gets prison, ordered to pay $12M for burning of 3rd Police Precinct

He was among four Minnesota men charged in connection to the fires at the Third Precinct following George Floyd's murder.


Some MN high schools are refusing to pay MSHSL's pandemic fee

The installment fees were approved as a "short-term" budget fix.

Grand Portage State Park

Senate GOP threatens State Parks, DNR shutdown if 'Clean Cars' rule isn't scrapped

Republicans are willing to hold up the omnibus environment bill to stop the MPCA from enacting Clean Cars rules.