The Willingham, Cuddyer conundrum

Even with Josh Willingham agreeing to a three-year deal worth $21-million, the Twins are still in contract talks with free-agent outfielder Michael Cuddyer. Nobody knows if Cuddyer will re-sign with the Twins, and the addition of Willingham has created a puzzling story.
Publish date:
Updated on

The Twins made the signing of Josh Willingham official Thursday. The former Oakland Athletics outfielder signed the dotted line on a three-year, $21-million contract. He is expected to start in left or right field.

Where Willingham starts depends on whether or not Michael Cuddyer re-signs with the Twins. Reports earlier this week indicated that Willingham's signing meant the end of Cuddyer's 11-year run in Minnesota.

The report was evidently inaccurate because general manager Terry Ryan says the Twins are still in talks with Cuddyer about returning.

The Cuddyer camp has been very quiet throughout this process and it's creating quite the puzzle. Will he re-sign or sign elsewhere. Star Tribune columnist Jim Souhan doesn't think Cuddyer will be back, but he says if Cuddyer does re-sign, it might be because the Twins don't think Justin Morneau will be healthy.

When and where Cuddyer signs is unknown, but if he decides to move on from Minnesota, it will be difficult for Willingham to replace him. Pioneer Press columnist Tom Powers believes Willingham's right-handed bat will be nice, but it will be impossible to replace one of baseball's real class acts.

Next Up


So far, Willingham outhitting Cuddyer

Twins outfielder Josh Willingham is swinging a bigger bat than the player he replaced on the Minnesota roster, Michael Cuddyer. Willingham has eight homers and 25 RBI so far. Cuddyer, playing with Colorado, has four homers and 23 RBI.

Twins still in contract talks with Cuddyer

Michael Cuddyer's time in Minnesota may come to an end soon, but as of now the Twins are still in contract talks with the free-agent outfielder. The Twins are also reportedly in the final stages of signing outfielder Josh Willingham, who could serve as Cuddyer's replacement.

Cuddyer on leaving: 'It's bittersweet'

Michael Cuddyer says moving on from Minnesota to sign with the Rockies is "bittersweet." Cuddyer also says he and his agent didn't have any conversations with the Twins after they signed Josh Willingham, but he doesn't have any hard feelings towards the organization.

Report: Twins to sign Willingham

The Twins have reportedly reached an agreement with free-agent outfielder Josh Willingham. The Star Tribune says the deal is worth an estimated $21 million over three years. Members of the Twins organization have confirmed talks with Willingham's agents, but would not confirm a deal had been reached.

Twins: Don't rule out Cuddyer just yet

The Minnesota Twins have signed Josh Willingham, and now they're sending out signals that there's a possibility he could sign Michael Cuddyer as well. As the Star Tribune puts it: hope is "rising internally."

Willingham wins Silver Slugger Award

After leading the Twins with 35 home runs and 110 runs batted in, Josh Willingham was named one of three American League outfielder to win a Silver Slugger Award, given to top offensive players.

Done deal: Twins sign Willingham

The Twins have announced they have come to terms with free agent outfielder Josh Wilingham. The deal is worth an estimated $21 million over three years.

Are Rockies now courting Cuddyer?

While the Twins await word from Michael Cuddyer on whether he'll accept their latest offer, the Colorado Rockies are suddenly showing interest in the free agent outfielder.